Originally Posted by Mel Maki
Some people are claiming the JP Morgan study shows lockdowns don't work if there is already a lot of virus in the area. They claim European countries that locked down have not done better than countries that didn't. They are claiming similar results in some areas of the US adding that 20 states coming out of the lockdown do not have raising rates. I would wait awhile before claiming a victory there.
Though the HK-China border passes 2.5 million a month and the government is not very effective they are claiming death is remarkable low because the citizens have dealt with SARS and Hong Kong Flu and are experts at social distancing.
Critics of lockdowns also say they destroy the health care system. Surveys show 4 out of 5 people are afraid to go to the ER for heart attacks, strokes, and other problems that can worsen. Cancer screenings are down 90%.
Deaths of despair are up 75,000, higher from no jobs, drug abuse, and alcohol abuse. They are claiming these deaths will be higher than virus deaths.
As usual, there's no links to anything you state, so there's no way to verify the veracity of them but I'm sure you can find all sorts of critics of lockdowns claiming whatever it is you think you've heard. "Deaths of despair are up 75,000, higher from no jobs, drug abuse, and alcohol abuse. They are claiming these deaths will be higher than virus deaths." There's always been deaths of despair from latter, especially with drug and alcohol abuse. But Covid19 is a +1, ie occuring in addition to those and not in substitution for them. A doctor from Columbia University today on CNN stated there likely would have been 37000 fewer deaths had the lockdownd been initiated earlier than they were. So there's two sides of the story here. Additionally, Mel, as you've noted before, compliance is a big problem in the states. Many don't social distance, wear masks and do whatever is necessary to avoid exposure, unlike what we seen in other countries. I do agree with you, however, when you state: "I would wait awhile before claiming a victory there." The latter in reference to states/countries coming out of lockdown...