Originally Posted by James Brown
I would have guessed that none of them would grant a reprieve in this sort of case.
Rod, the Navarro case is a nit. The two First Amendment Cases heard yesterday are a big deal. I think in the more important
Murthy v. Missouri matter the Court will merely confirm that
existing First Amendment law applies to social media. In other words the government can exert pressure on the platform owners to censor only when there is a compelling state interest. Then I think that the Court will conclude that the government overreached way too much in the Covid years. I think the vote(s) in both cases will be 7-2 or 6-3 with Brown-Jackson and maybe Sotomayor in the minority. Kagan has shown real free speech chops in the past IIRC, and will side with the conservative justices.
Any opinion on this?