Originally Posted by James Lacey
Your numbers are misleading for a couple of reasons.
Under Trump, the S& P increased by 1,554 points, but under Biden, it increased by 1,959 points. So, the S& increased a lot more in points under Biden than it did under Trump.
It's also true that a percentage increase in an index doesn't translate to an exact increase in your portfolio. It depends on what you are invested in. If your portfolio consists mainly of bonds and treasuries, you will do worse during a stock market boom than someone invested in large-cap and equity stocks.
I looked at all the major indexes, and under Biden, they have gone up a lot more in points than they did under Trump. In short, percentage increases don't tell the whole story, and even if you do look at percentage increases, it still looks like Biden performed as well or better. It's also true that percentage increases get smaller in points over time since the index always rises. In other words, a 1,000-point increase when the index is 2,000 looks much better than a 1,000-point increase when the index is 3,000.
I also asked my financial advisor, a family member who works for Fidelity in wealth management and planning, and some friends and family whose stock market and economy have been better for investors. Without fail, they all without hesitation said Biden's has been much better, which agrees with my experience as well.
Hi James: you and Richard are both, probably intentionally, missing the larger point in my opinion. Attached is a screen cap from my phone right now of the S& 500 For the past 10 years. The other major indices have generally speaking the same types of 10 year graphs. The stock market has thrived over the past eight years, even though there were massive downturns when Covid hit, and at the height of the inflationary period. Me, and other buy and hold investors who have wealth in low-cost index funds have no complaints whatsoever about overall stock market performance under either administration.
The market has been strong in the face of significant challenges like Covid, and my conclusion is that our economy/system are indeed amazingly robust, no matter who happens to be in the oval office.
I suppose Trump or Harris could screw it up badly in the next term, but I remain confident that the markets, and our overall economy, will recover because our system is just that strong. J