Originally Posted by James Lacey
Individually, I agree with many of their policies. I suspect many Americans do too. Overall, though, their platform's branding and messaging won't be effective or relatable, and it's a target-rich environment for identity attacks and mischaracterizations. My favorite example is when Democrats originated the phrase "defund the police," or even better, "decriminalize border crossings." People attacked and mischaracterized these policies based on those phrases alone, without ever trying to understand them. They will do the same with this platform.
I think many Americans agree that reform on some of these
topics would be OK. Healthcare and prescription drug cost reform are two topics the poll well, for example. Lots of people favor some sort of orderly immigration reform, while keeping a closed border. Lots of people think Israel has been heavy-handed in Gaza etc. etc.
I seriously doubt that many Americans would agree with the
policies as set forth in this platform on those topics. I suppose, if you went through with a fine toothed comb one could find a policy, expressed in the DSA's own paper using their own words, that is not crazy. I did not see any. I'd be surprised if you can quote one policy from this paper you would endorse "as written" without also quoting 10 you think are crazy!
Some of their policies are endgame dangerous. Eliminating our Constitutional checks and balances by eliminating the the judicial branch and executive branch will inevitably lead to a totalitarian dictatorship, if history is any guide. Same with the elimination of police and incarceration as punishment. As if the evil aspects of human nature were going to be wished away!
They published this for a reason though, and it is to attract those voters who feel entitled to free housing and medicine, free education in whatever arcane subject pleases them, paying no bills whatsoever, while working 32 hours a week with unlimited leave at a cool job guaranteed by the government! All for a living wage, while the poor Palestinians get Israel from the river to the sea, including Jerusalem. Wonder what we'll do with the Israelis?
Of course, I realize that none of this weak minded socialist nonsense stands a chance of being implemented as written. I'm shocked they wrote it, as it exposes the silliness of our DSA movement. My guess is that the vast majority of the voters who primaried DSA candidates over conventional Democrats think that American-style socialism is something vague and limited, along the lines of "healthcare like they have in Denmark" and
not this litany of truly crappy ideas. My guess is that their vote is a reaction against some injustice or another they believe is inherent in our system, and not in any way a reasoned consideration of the tragic fate of freedom in the western hemisphere if many of these policies were to be implemented as written. Jim