Protostar 3 vane versus curved spiderPosted By Dave Adams |
Thanks for all the input. I spoke with Bryan at Protostar and felt comfortable with the curved vane. He said they have tried different designs over the last 2 years and are confident they have a good design that addresses the stability issue while using thin vane material. The curved spider uses the same thickness material as the 3 vane spider so overall diffraction should be less. The vanes are wider at the base to help with stability. I might not have gotten this correct but there is a plate mounted somewhere on the vanes that acts as damper. Since this scope will be used mostly for planet and lunar viewing, I opted to order it in the 1" size along with a new secondary. I hope I don't find the vignetting objectionable but I don't think I will be using this scope very often for wide field viewing.
Dave Adams
Dave Adams