Tempted, ... BUT.....

Started by light trap, 01/11/2004 02:49PM
Posted 01/11/2004 02:49PM Opening Post
I gotta say that I've been sorely tempted by various Burgess scopes ever since I met Bill a couple years ago. With the latest crop of 1278s appearing here on Amart in the $300 range, it's a tempting proposition. QC issues not withstanding, it looks to be a heck of a deal. However, when I think about the fact that I don't have a suitable mount, and think about the reality of a 13lb, meter long scope, I have to wonder if it would really do anything that some of my other scopes won't already do.

For instance, I'd dearly love to see a detailed comparitive review of the Burgess 1278 vs a lowly Orion XT4.5 . I might expect the Burgess 1278 to beat the "kid's scope" at high power, but I wonder what it'd really come down to? It'd also be interesting to compare it to a 6" or 8" garden variety Asian DOB. Perhaps no diffraction spikes, in exchange for a tinge of chromatic abberation? Hmmmm....

Mike Swaim
Posted 01/11/2004 03:05PM #1
>>For instance, I'd dearly love to see a detailed comparitive review of the Burgess 1278 vs a lowly Orion XT4.5 . I might expect the Burgess 1278 to beat the "kid's scope" at high power, but I wonder what it'd really come down to? It'd also be interesting to compare it to a 6" or 8" garden variety Asian DOB. Perhaps no diffraction spikes, in exchange for a tinge of chromatic abberation? Hmmmm....

Mike Swaim
-------

I just don't seeing this scope being comparable to the garden variety 8 inch DOB, its giving away too much aperture and my experience with my XT-8 is that it does a good job. I had the 120mm F8.3 Synta scope, yeah, it produced some nice images, nice on doubles, OK on DSOs and planets but only on doubles was it comparable to the DOB.

The problem I see is that a meter long refractor is getting to be a pretty big scope so it takes a CG-5 or better to really handle it. This starts to be a pretty big operation and one that is not always so comfortable to use. Kneeling in the dirt to see a target near the zenith is not my idea of a good time...

jon