Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

What's Really Up?

Started by jadamslh, 02/16/2004 12:55AM
Posted 02/16/2004 12:55AM Opening Post
I've seen a few posts on this and other Burgess-centered forums from folks who apparently have no investment in Burgess products, but who carp, cavil, and snipe at Burgess' new products. I'm wondering, why? What's it to you?

I understand getting frustrated at Bill's poor communication with us. I've talked and e-mailed him about this, and it's just what he does [doesn't] do.

I'm one who sees the potential for great values and innovative products from Bill. Maybe he's more of a visionary than a businessman, I don't know. But, is he a scammer, a flim-flam man? Hardly. He's one of US, who has seized the opportunity to provide products of high value to cost ratio to other amateurs. No cynicism, no exploitation, no real "hype", only enthusiasm.

I have a set of BO WA and SWA eyepieces for evaluation [see Burgess yahoo groups]. There is a clinker, and a couple of [IMO] SUPER values among them. The poor one may be the result of a manufacturing glitch, or the Chardonnay. But the good ones were compared against some pretty good eyepieces.

But, back to my point, while I can understand the frustration of those who waited SOOOOO long for their scopes, what axe is being ground by those who haven't had to wait, or been disappointed with the product?

I have my 1278, #18, and have found it more than satisfactory. Still waiting for the 1026, but I have other scopes, and I had one to evaluate, and was very impressed with it. BTW, my friend William, who was set up near me last week with his AP 7" said, upon viewing through the BO 1278, "hey, nice image!" And it was.

So, before you take some of the critics very seriously, maybe ask yourself what their motives might be.
Posted 02/16/2004 01:51AM #1
James, you pose a very good question. But, I would not assume that there is necessarily a conspiracy against Bill Burgess. I haven't posted on this forum, and I must be watching it more for its soap-opera value than for any real purpose. I personally believe that there is a good product in there somewhere.

But, this is something of a textbook case in how not to start up a company. Over-hype followed by a lack ofcommunication and results. Recently the forums have turned up a number of newcomers asking about the Burgess eyepieces with wide fields and low prices. I tend to stay out of these things, but if a really live personal friend asked me about Burgess off line, I'd say "Wait until they get their act together and and some independent reviews come out before even thinking about it."
Posted 02/17/2004 01:29PM #2
>>>So, before you take some of the critics very seriously, maybe ask yourself what their motives might be.

You pass off the frustations of those of us waitng on the list for a year and then getting inoperable equipment rather lightly. Waiting a year for a scope that was promised in a month and then when it arrives has serious problems is not something to be taken lightly. In my case, the 1026 that I received is unusable because of astigmatism. The scope never should have been shipped.

Seeing a potential for great values is all fine and dandy, I have been doing that for a year along with many others. But one must also estabish creditablity by living up to promises one makes.

Back to questioning peoples motives... This an open forum where anyone is free to post, posts are not deleted or people expelled just because they disagree with the moderator. In those closed moderated forums, sometimes it seems they are expelled because the information they provide is damaging, though true. I will not participate in any group that is moderated by someone with a possible ulterior agenda.

If Don Dickenson wants to rag on Burgess Optical, he is free to do so for whatever reason, he has not provided false information. Burgess Optical has provided him with all the ammunition he needs.

So, in a previous post, I have explained my motives, I want there to be a friendly and free exchange of ideas and information so that people can make an informed decision.

But while you question the motives of others, I suggest that you should explore your own motives. My guess is that in questioning the motives of others, you have your own hidden agenda. It is pretty clear what that might be, given your close ties with BO.

In forums like this, it is clear that we all are coming from some personal point of view. And that is just fine, yours, mine, Don's, they all go together to give anyone reading this forum, something to think about.

Jon Isaacs