Image of the day

Captured by
james carter

North American Nebula NGC7000

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Re: TV 102 and a new Astro-Physics 130

Started by John Finnan, 09/30/2003 03:56AM
Posted 09/30/2003 03:56AM Opening Post
Robert, I recently upgraded my NP-101 for an NP-127 which I've had an opportunity to use quite a lot over the past month. Naturally, I would not have made that expensive upgrade unless I thought that I would gain a significant performance boost from it.

In most respects the NP-127 performs the way that I expected it would. That is, nebulas are both brighter and show more nebulosity. Globular Clusters like M5, M13 & M22 show many more individual stars but are not really well resolved not would I expect them to be in a 5-inch scope. On the moon and the planets I can go to higher powers while retaining a sharper image. However, most of the objects that great in the NP-127 also look pretty nice in the NP-101. To use an analogy, I'd say the NP-101 is like a Porsche 911 sports car and the NP-127 is a like a 911 turbo. There is a significant and noticeable difference in performance but it is not a radical difference. Nevertheless, I'm pleased with the NP-127. But, knowing what I know now, if I still had a NP-101 and I did not have a set of Nagler eyepieces or a Bino Vue, that is where I'd invest me money before upgrading to a NP-127. But, since I already had the Naglers and Bino Vue upgrading the OTA was the only thing left I could do to improve the overall performance on my system. I fairly certain the NP-127 will be the end of the line for me.

The category in which I noticed the greatest difference was when using a binoviewer. Some of the brighter DSOs look good/great in a NP-101 but not many. Those same objects look better in the NP-127 but more importantly (for me anyway), is that many objects that don't look so good (or so-so at best) in the NP-101 look good/very good in the NP-127. To me this was the most important (and desired) performance gain that I've got with the NP-127.

The reason that I was willing to pay big bucks for a 5-inch rather than using that money to get a Tak, TEC or TMB 6-incher was because I prefer the shorter focal length and rich field options of the NP-101/NP-127 type of scope and the fact that they are small and light enough to use with a Gibraltar Mount.

On the color issue with your AP-130, have you had a chance to use it with Saturn yet and have you seen any false color with it? I don't know how to account for your 40x splitting on the double-double with the TV-102. The lowest power that I've seen in split at (in another friend's TV-102) is 98x. The 87x split you got with the AP-130 sounds about right to me, not 40x with a TV-102. Do you have any other astronomer friends who have seen it split at that power through your TV-102?

Anyway, I hope my post gives you some idea of what to expect with respect to a performance gain between a four-inch apo and a 5-inch. If you're looking for a bigger boost than that perhaps you’d be happier with a 6-incher. One of the many good things about your AP-130 is that is should be easy to resell.