Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

12.5" vs. 15" DOB?

Started by fblue, 02/04/2004 05:54PM
Posted 02/04/2004 05:54PM Opening Post
I have a chance to buy a 12.5" f/4.8 DOB made by the same person that made my scope. The optics are Meade and it is in good condition, used little and stored in a dry place. I have a 15" f/4.9 DOB now.
I am wondering if it would be worth buying it for a second DOB? I sometimes would like a DOB that I can stand flat footed and observe and this would achieve that goal.
Would a 12.5" give comparable views? I have only looked through two 12.5" DOBs and I must admit I did not pay enough attention to them to remember how the view was in them.
So, what is the opiinion of those that have used both these sizes.
I understand that my Swayze 15" mirror is probably a better mirror than the 12.5" Meade, so I am talking about aperture only.
Thanks,
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 02/04/2004 06:11PM #1
Well, if you already have a good 15", I am not sure why you would want a 12.5" of probably lesser quality (meade vs. Swayze...). If you want a smaller scope because the 15" is too much to drag out, I don't think the 12.5" is going to be that much easier to use, especially if it is a solid tube. If that is the case, I would say go down to something like an 8" f6, 6" f8, or small refractor for a second quick look scope.

Jarad
Posted 02/04/2004 07:45PM #2
Floyd, must be nice to be in such a "predicament"...
smile

Personally, IMHO, I think you already have a very nice setup, and a well covered range, with your 8" and your 15".
If you are looking for comfort of viewing, and your 15" turns out to be too long, might want to see if you could sell it, and with that money plus what you were going to invest in the 12.5", get, as Jarad said, a StarMaster 14.5" which IS a shorter length scope, still providing awesome views & great quality all around.


Just a thought,



Ivan
smile

Ivan Gastaldo 8)
Coconut Creek, FL

Ivan's Observatory
Lat 26N 16' 48" Long 80W 10' 48"
[COLOR="Red"]Personal Website:[/COLOR] http://www.ivangastaldo.com

CCD Imaging and Processing/Deep Sky - Moderator
I like to complain about everything - Moderator
Posted 02/04/2004 09:05PM #3
Floyd, the 12.5" has about 31% less light grasp than the 15". That's less than a magnitude. Both focal ratios are nearly the same. So, if other factors are equivalent (or nearly so), such as coating reflectivity, relative size of secondary mirror, thermal management, then visually I would expect:
- Stars will look a little less bright then in the 15", but not by much. For example, globulars won't look quite as good.
- With the same eyepieces, extended objects (like nebulae, galaxies, planets) will have about the same brightness, but will appear a little smaller.
- With the same eyepieces, the sky background will have about the same darkness.
- Real FOV in your eyepieces will be a little bigger.
- At high magnifications, the larger Swayze mirror ought to give better resolution, but you probably won't be able to tell except on nights of exceptional atmospheric seeing. Of course, if the Meade mirror is a dog, then you may notice more of the time.

Wish I had your kind of problems (we won't talk about the kind I do have, tho!).

Good luck,
Doug Scobel
Posted 02/05/2004 12:27AM #4
You should buy it and send it to me for evaluation. I'll send it back in about a year with my recommendation. Heck, I'll even pay shipping to return it to you then. ;-)