Image of the day

Captured by
RICHARD COFER

M 81

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

D&G 5" vs AP 130 f/6

Started by adamsdp, 03/14/2004 04:57PM
Posted 03/14/2004 04:57PM Opening Post
I was very fortunate to purchase a used D&G 5" f/10 a few months ago and have been very happy with the views. The optics in the D&G are outstanding and really pull away from several of the Chineese refractors I have at high power. I am wondering how much difference there is between a D&G 5" and an AP 130mmf/6 on planetary/lunar viewing.

I put myself on the wait list for an AP 130 f/6 and know that I will never be sorry in getting one. I am just curious how much of an improvement it will provide over the D&G I have. I have a Baader Contrast Booster filter which acts as a minus violet filter but haven't felt the need to use it yet. I am going to try that out and think about getting a chromacorr. I have done more reading
about refractor optics and it seems spherical aberration is more important than the chromatic aberrations and that really good achromats like the D&G do a better job at limting chromatic aberrations than the Chineese refractors. That being said, the D&G is a really nice scope and I am tempted to get a 5" f/10 or f/12 just to get the upgraded AP focuser and adjustable lense cell that mine does not have.
Posted 03/14/2004 05:28PM #1
You can probably order just the AP focuser with matching backplate from D&G. May take a while due to the AP backlog, but no longer than ordering a new scope.
Dom Q.
Posted 03/14/2004 07:16PM #2
"I am wondering how much difference there is between a D&G 5" and an AP 130mmf/6 on planetary/lunar viewing."

For planetary viewing the AP 130 f/8.35 would be preferable to the f/6 version.