Image of the day

Captured by
Byron Davies

M-20 Trifid Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

equipment dilemma- warning: long preamble

Started by glennd, 12/17/2004 01:06AM
Posted 12/17/2004 01:06AM Opening Post
Hi folks. I’m thinking about rearranging my scope line up once and for all. I do a mix of dso’s and planets with a little time on double stars. I run a high school astronomy program where there is plenty of imaging equipment to use. 95% of my telescope time at home is spent with an eyepiece in the scope, although I can see more web cam projects on the horizon as my kids get older. Over the years, I’ve owned scopes of many designs and in many sizes. When I lived in a big city, I settled on a 4” apo on an alt az mount. I could take it outside and view planets or load it in the car and be observing dso’s in 2 hours. It was a great solution. I’ve been in Vermont now for 7 years where the 4” didn’t seem so ideal anymore, or at least one size no longer seemed to fit all. Standing in my driveway on good nights, M33 is a naked eye object. These new conditions triggered an amazingly time consuming trial of many scopes in search of an ideal combination that fit my budget. It was fun to try all that equipment though. Several years ago, I ordered a 5” f/12 achromat and I thought I was pretty close to done. I have it on a very nice gem and can be observing with it in about 5 minutes. It’s wonderful. Add a quick look scope and something big and I’m done, right? Guess not. Aside from having too much money in scopes, my big scope sat unused. Too big for me to bother with. Guess that makes me lazy, because it was a truss scope I could leave assembled and roll out the door in seconds. Turns out I’m not a ladder guy. I’m thinking about a two scope line up. Currently I have a 78mm apo and my 5” achromat. Nice, but something is missing. The 5” does a great job on dso’s but it is still a 5”. I’m getting a hankering for a 10” f/6 newt that I could move between an alt az mount and a gem. This diameter and focal ratio seems ideal to me. Not huge, not expensive (as these things go) and great views. It also would not require a wildly huge and expensive gem. I’m pretty intrigued with Bob Royce’s conical primaries. I would really enjoy building up a scope around one. Here is the problem: I would need to sell one of my current scopes to make this happen, so which one? I suspect a well set up 10” Royce will do nearly everything that my 5” will do but better. I can still see a roll for the 78mm apo for quick peeks and nights when I’m in the mood for fishing with light tackle (fairly frequent). I never thought I’d say this, but I might sell my 5” f/12 achromat. If I’m wrong about this, then I’ve sold a scope that is very difficult to replace, one that I enjoy using every time I go out, and also a sentimental favorite. I suppose I could sell several eyepieces which are more easily replaced after I have a chance to make a more informed choice. That would almost be a solution, but funds would still be a bit short.

Sorry for the ramble. I welcome your input.
Thanks,
Glenn
Posted 12/17/2004 02:54AM #1
"Hi folks. I’m thinking about rearranging my scope line up once and for all. "

Ha ha ha! How many times have I done this? But I'm still trying. It sure is fun! Seems like every time I get the "perfect" setup, I use it for a while, then lose interest. After a pause, I start looking at equipment again, and it picks up my interest. "Wow! Wonder what I could see with THAT?" And so on...

It's a great way to enjoy the hobby.
Posted 12/17/2004 08:40PM | Edited 12/17/2004 08:43PM #2
Hi Glenn,

>>
[COLOR="Blue"][SIZE="Small"]Standing in my driveway on good nights, M33 is a naked eye object. These new conditions triggered an amazingly time consuming trial of many scopes in search of an ideal combination that fit my budget. It was fun to try all that equipment though.[/SIZE][/COLOR]
<<

M33 Naked eye !! ??

Go for the aperture ! Deep sky is now your calling. 12" minimum ! The cheap 12" imports will get you very far down the road. If your adventurous and handy with fixing scopes, the Meade 16" dob is an amazing deal. These scopes need some tuning up, but they really deliver the goods. There were a bunch of these at RTMC a few years ago, and the couple that I looked through gave sharp low power views. Some were only modified with new focusers and squeeked a little in azimuth, but really gave >deep< sky views. Yes I looked through the 20+ inch scopes there as well, but for the $$ the Meade could not be touched. Chances are you won't be needing a ladder either.

David Simons

David Simons