HELP: f-ratio as Finicky collimation factor

Started by toml, 09/09/2003 03:45PM
Posted 09/09/2003 03:45PM Opening Post
I have heard that faster than f6, a newt starts to get finicky about needing collimation each time you go out, or being harder and harder to get it dead on. with bigger dobs though, you don't always have the luxury of a long FL, so for me at 5'11" (plus 1' for standing on my EP case) and a 13.1" mirror that's about 4" off the ground at zenith, I figure that f5.25 is my theoretical limit, but sure maybe f5.5 if I don't mind waiting for the odd thing at absolute zenith to 'move'. In that case, maybe a different step stool, or maybe a little more waiting could possibly maybe talk me into an f6, but that would give up some ease of use (tip toes + storage + bulk etc), which I really want to avoid if possible.

Still, finicky collimation impacts usability too, so what I want to know is:

what difference to the 'finicky' factor does f5.25, f5.5, and f6 make. I know we're not talking ultra fast or slow here, but a fine grained 'dialing' in on the usability/need for fine collimation versus quick and dirty being 'good enough' but as I get ready to refigure my mirror, I want to know what I should shoot for in trading off quick n dirty is good enough (that's good) with super tall scopes (not so good).

Thanks!
TomL
Posted 09/09/2003 03:54PM #1
I have an f/5.7 dob and its easy to collimate. Bob Royce has a good article on collimating Newtonians and another on coma(at rfroyce.com); he describes Newtoians of f 5.5 and up as being a relaxed system.
There seems to be some agreement that it gets noticeably more finnicky below f/5.
I would not go futher without reading the royce articles.
Posted 09/09/2003 04:01PM #2
There is no simple answer. I personally think that collimation isn't that big a deal. But I have a 10" f4.5 scope with fiberglass tube. It seems to hold collimation well. I usually just tweak the primary while observing a star at high power.

Of course, a big truss tube scope is a different animal. On those collimation may be pretty far off every time it is put together. Or it may just need tweaking of the primary.

So there is no one answer. If your scope needs to have the secondary collimated every time it is set up, it doesn't matter if it is f4.5 or f6. It will still be annoying every time. If you just need to tweak the primary, it will be fast and simple.

If the mechanical parts of the scope are such that collimation is very tricky, focal ratio might matter more, but you still will need to get used to the process at any focal ratio. I think the mechanical aspects are far more important than the difference between f5 and f6.

All MO, of course, and worth every penny you paid for this opinion.
Posted 09/09/2003 04:17PM #3
I have a 14.5" f/4.3 Starmaster. Precise collimation is absolutely no problem - takes me maybe 2 minutes max and then maybe 2 minutes again after a few hours if needed at all. IMO the whole fear factor of collimation with faster newts is a lotta hype. But, yeah, there is a bigger collimation sweet spot with a slower mirror.

Doug