Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

How many cheap scopes before......?

Started by light trap, 01/11/2004 04:39PM
Posted 01/11/2004 04:39PM Opening Post
Just a general question for folks; how many inexpensive and downright cheap scopes did you have to buy before moving up in quality?

I'm kind of unusal in that I started out with good scopes, (Intes Micro M603 and MN56), and have been moving backwards on the quality scale ever since. (Celestron 90mm Mak, Astro Rubinar 100mm Mak, TV Ranger, Orion XT4.5, JMI Next Gen 6", Discovery 6", Hardin DSH-8; just to name a few.)

I know what I really need to do: buy a Mag1 12.5" Portaball or 14.5" Starmaster. But, I seem to be psychologically incapable of spending that much, even though I know I'd enjoy them. Even though I know that's what I really *should* do, I still find myself shopping in the cheap market more often than not. It's kind of ironic.

So how long, on average does it take for folks to come to the "quality is best" way of thinking and quit hoping for too much out of too little?

Mike Swaim
Posted 01/11/2004 04:46PM #1
My first scope was a Gilbert 40x reflector, which was a Christmas present. My second was a 60mm Unitron refractor, which, while not "cheap," was too small in aperture to hold much interest for the planetary views I desired. My third was a homemade 8" f/8 Newt, which kept me happy for many years. For an 8", the views left little to be desired.

Clear skies, Alan
Posted 01/11/2004 04:59PM #2
Hi Mike:

It may not be that easy. Quality is an elusive and ill defined metric. To many, it is the fit and finish of the exterior of the telescope. Others, get off on the "feel" of the focuser and knowing they paid more than most for their "treasure". Most consider optical performance as the chief consideration but then argue over hardware components. For example, a specific refractor is good but it's long focal length makes it difficult to mount. Now we can spend the next several months discussing which mount can survive a nuclear blast. I find that having a few telescopes of various f/#s is a safe way to avoid the trap. Since I do not have unlimited funds, I select a telescope (usually not a premium scope) that seems meet a specific viewing objective. Is there something better out there ....sure. There is always something better - but if you are happy with the views, what is the point?
Posted 01/11/2004 07:07PM #3
Mike,

Dec 2002: Orion XT4.5 dob, not cheap, inexpensive, but 4.5" nonetheless

Feb 2003: Orion XT10 dob, again, not cheap, affordable and a great value. I loved that scope.

May 2003: Celestron ST80, 80mm f/5 refractor, sitting on my workbench right now, thinking about selling it

Oct 2003: Burgess 5" refractor. Got the big refractor bug, lost it a week later when I bought...

Nov 2003: 11" Starmaster with a Zambuto mirror.

Looking back, there is no way I should have started with the Starmaster. I learned a lot with the first scopes. I learned how to collimate and how to observe. I gained experience with viewing objects and gleaning fine details. I bought binoviewers and ep's galore. I built an eq platform and an observing chair. I learned how to relax and enjoy just looking at the moon one evening, or just M42 for an hour. I spent an entire evening in dark skies at my parents house just looking at the stars with my eyes. I learned the night sky. I figured out what M meant. I joined a club and found out how wonderful astronomers are. I learned about other types of telescopes, and aperture and the value of dark skies. I learned about seeing and how even the most expensive telescope can be made to look bad by mother nature.

Had I not gained all of that experience before I bought the Starmaster, I think the added capability that such a masterful instrument brings would have been lost on me. My inexperience, and in some cases ineptness, would have hidden what a great mirror has to offer.

To answer your question, 11 wonderful months.

Clear skies,

Tom
Posted 01/11/2004 09:50PM #4
first: wanted to buy a CHEAP scope. talked out of it and into binocs. still succummed and bought cheap binocs (10x50s with each eye pointed at a different angle!) got a refund (and escaped learning a lesson about cheap optics quickly and for free).

second: bought 10x50 Nikon Actions for $140 and now felt at 3x the price of the first ones that I got a BARGAIN, you know that feeling? they cost 3x as much and the views were 100x better. I fell in love with open clusters.

third: researched, asked here and there, and learned about good starter scopes (i hated that term, thinking i would only ever need one scope...wrong!) came down to a GS 8 or 10 (ie. XT8 or XT10). Chose the 8 for size/value after looking at jupiter through both (should have looked at M13 to tell the difference) saw no diff and got the 8.

happy i did because optics aside, i liked how easy it was to lug around in one piece. and I used it...a LOT...because of that. if the optics were crap I wouldn't have. if it were fussy to use or set up, I wouldn't have. It is neither and I miss it smile

fourth: bought a garage sale Nexstar 8 for CHEAP. Unimpressed by the soft views (collimated) I sold the ota (see how my tastes start to get more discriminating? Not saying C8s are soft, just my particular example didn't impress me). Replaced it with an Intes MK67 and my standards were higher now, and for good. Inky black skies, refractor like sharp stars and contrast. Mmmmm..

fifth: sold the xt8 and started building around a swayze 13.1 and nova secondary. I don't think this will go on, but I feel like i've been led to where my standards have been increased by slow and steady exposure to better optics (so yes, starting not TOO low and working up was good to me), nor are my desires unquenchable...I'm starting to settle in to my sweet spot, like audio or video gear at a certain point: it cost 10x more to get to the next step.

I've discovered I like sharp optics and contrasty views and also solid mountings/smooth feel to the instrument. I've also discovered I don't care about goto, and that EPs are just as important to giving me the views I myself now require. Pentax XL are my favourite 'keepers'.

Starting with any of this would have been wasted on me, but the lousy binos (refund) were a WASTE. Nothing after would I consider cheap. Inexpensive yes (XT8 is $300 used), but seriously, if I had to sell my Swayze and Intes, and Pentax EPs, and just look through an XT8 with the included plossls, I would miss the inky backgrounds and sharp optics of the others, but honestly, that scope really is "good enough" to look around forever. So I COULD live with one BUT my tastes now dictate I step up (happily so) for a little more money. Still, at some point I can't take the next $tep because it's logarithmic not linear.

You have to start small to know the difference I think, know what YOU like and then "value" can be found at any price point.

Tom.
Posted 01/11/2004 10:13PM #5
*grin*

I cheated. I hung around using other peoples scopes at Star Parties and with friends for 3 years... before ordering a 12.5" Portaball.

Uh... but then couldn't wait for delivery and picked up a Nexstar 8 and a 4" APO in the last 18 months... so I guess it didn't help completely to do it that way!

Karl
Posted 01/11/2004 10:57PM #6
Mike wrote:
---
I know what I really need to do: buy a Mag1 12.5" Portaball or 14.5" Starmaster.
---
I was in the same place last winter, and I purchased a used 12.5" Mag1 Portaball. After using it for almost a year, my desire for a new telescope has vanished. When you finally have a telescope with great optics, you'll know that on any given night your equipment won't be the limiter. So my advice to you: do what you need to do!

(Note that my desire for eyepieces, an equatorial platform, etc. has definitely NOT vanished.)
Posted 01/11/2004 11:35PM #7
This is an interesting forum. During the past few years, I've used Astromart to "rent" various scopes to learn what my longterm preferences are. Star parties and clubs were a very good start; on the other hand, actually having to set up a scope, learn about its design compromises, and use it on a nightly basis taught me a great deal as to what I find acceptable, as well as what type of observing that I like to do.

I started out quite a few years ago with a 6" equatorial reflector. After being away from the hobby for several years, I purchases a Meade ETX 90, which I liked for it's sharp views, but disliked because of the noise and added complexity of its electronics.

The ETX was sold to buy a C8; this, too, was nice, but I didn't like the long cool down or the size of the scope. On a whim, I purchased a Celestron 80 achromat and liked the scope's form factor. The C8 was sold, the Celestron 90 given to a friend, and I bought a Pronto.

I really liked the Pronto a great deal. It was small, easy to use, and offered great views. The desire for more aperature hit, and I sold the Pronto and bought at TV85.

The TV85 was a great scope--the only problem was that I discovered that I like solar observing and it was difficult to reach the Coronado tuner while observing because of the length of the tube.

I now have two scopes. A TV76, which I primarily use for H-alpha solar observing and the occasional peek at night; a MiniBorg 50 fitted with a white light filter that I keep in my office for quick views of the sun during the workday.

This was a somewhat winding path, but I finally discovered the scopes that are best for me. Think carefully about the types of observing that you plan on doing and how much time that you can realistically devote to the hobby.

Now, if I only can get that *second" SM60 filter....

Don
Posted 01/12/2004 02:08AM #8
Posted 01/12/2004 02:42PM #9
>>Just a general question for folks; how many inexpensive and downright cheap scopes did you have to buy before moving up in quality?
--------

If you want to try out a cheap scope, I suggest going to Big Lots, they have a refractor for $7.95 that is supposed to be something like an 40x and 45mm aperture but it has an aperture stop and is essentially plastic.

jon