Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Information on Planetary Scopes

Started by lthaxton, 03/05/2004 08:18PM
Posted 03/05/2004 08:18PM Opening Post
I am considering shifting around some of my equipment in yet another step toward finding "the best planetary scope." Living near Los Angeles limits deepsky opportunities to the occasional road trip so this is to be an in-town scope. At the moment I am using an AP 6" F/12 Superplanetary and a D&G 8" F/12, both of which have excellent optics. An observatory is being considered and I am balking a bit at the size I will need to house the D&G on its HD 150.

The scopes that I have been looking at are the TEC 250 F/20, Tak Mewlon 250 (love the 300 but $$ has to be considered at some point!), TOA 170 (someone say something about $$??) and the TEC 180 APO. The AP 10" Mak would be on the list but after three years on their list for a 155, I am aready a bit tired of waiting.

Anyway, has anyone had a chance to compare the various 250s? Thoughts on performance of the TOA or TEC APOs v the 250 maks? I have been looking at some of the dark sky sites I frequent but have yet to have a chance to view through either the 250 Tak or TEC.

Posted 03/05/2004 08:30PM #1
Have you considered a newtonian? The scopes you already have are excellent planetary scopes, so they will be hard to beat, but something like a 12.5" f5 Portaball (on eq. platform), or a 12.5" or 14.5" Starmaster (with Goto), or one of Rob Teeter's Planet Killer long f-ratio scopes also make great planetary scopes and are cheaper than some of the ones you already listed.

If you already have a 150mm AP scope and a 200mm D&G, I am not sure that you will get a lot of improvement from a 170mm or 180mm scope, so I would narrow down to the larger scopes (the TEC or Tak 250's, or one of the newtonians mentioned above).

Unless you are planning to use it for astrophotgraphy, in which case the cassegrains would be better than a newt.

Jarad
Posted 03/05/2004 11:25PM #2
The best views of the planets I have ever had was through a 12.5" f/5 Starmaster.
Posted 03/06/2004 03:19AM #3
"Anyway, has anyone had a chance to compare the various 250s? Thoughts on performance of the TOA or TEC APOs v the 250 maks? I have been looking at some of the dark sky sites I frequent but have yet to have a chance to view through either the 250 Tak or TEC."

The TEC250/20 in my opinion is probably the finest 10" planetary scope out there, it is designed for high power use, it is a special purpose instrument with very limited applications, but what it does it does it real well. Cooldown is the only issue that need be considered with this instrument