Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Interesting side by side

Started by tomhole, 11/23/2003 07:19AM
Posted 11/23/2003 07:19AM Opening Post
At tonight's star gathering by our club, there were 3 pretty nice scopes. One was a Mark Harry mirrored 10" truss, another was a Zambuto 12.5" portaball and the third was our club's CGE1400 14"SCT in our observatory.

The seeing was very good at a solid 7 of 10 with moments of very steady views. I looked through the 3 scopes several times at 400-450x on Saturn. Without a doubt, the 12.5" Zambuto was the winner, the 10" Harry was a close second and the CGE1400 was third. I'm not sure about the dob's collimation, but the CGE1400 has been collimated by our club's SCT owners.

I had expected the 14" to stomp on everyone else in this most excellent seeing. But the view was not as sharp as the 2 dobs. If that is due to collimation, I would be suprised as our club has some pretty experienced SCT users, but I guess you never know. I can say for certain that my 5" Burgess was left behind in this comparison, but I wouldn't expect a 5" scope of any type to keep up with the bigger dobs.

So now I'm left wondering why I have a 5" refractor. It is the first refractor I have ever looked through. I didn't expect the 5" to keep up with the 10", but I had to try a refractor to see what they are like. Maybe there was something I was missing with the 10" dob that I could get from the 5" refractor. I have an Orion XT10 that shows much more on the planets and deep sky, which is my main interest. The pinpoint stars are nice. It is only slightly more portable than my dob. It shakes like a leaf on the stock Apogee HD. I'll have to mull this one over.

Anyway, just thinking out loud.

Clear skies,

Tom
Posted 11/23/2003 08:43AM #1
I saw somewhat similar results at the last Winter Star
Party. There was a 11" StarMaster (Zambuto) which
was showing slightly better detail on Jupiter than a
14" SCT. There was also a 10" Mak-Cass (planetary optimized)
and a 10" APO which were showing details fairly
similar to the 14" SCT. My impression was the 14" SCT
provided some of the the best planetary views per dollar
(after the StarMaster), but somewhat under-performed
per inch of aperture. Potential reasons might include
the larger central obstruction, longer time to reach
thermal equilibrium, collimation, etc.
Posted 11/23/2003 06:05PM #2
Nice observing report. This is nothing new to those of us that have Zambuto mirrors - go get one!
Posted 11/23/2003 06:25PM #3
I would ask one question about the comparison.
Were all the scopes using the same EP and magnification?
This can make a hugh difference! An EP can make much better contrast or details in a scope.
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 11/24/2003 02:46AM #4
Tom,

I have a 12.5" Portaball. I know what you mean when you say that the Portaball can produce great images without even seeming to work hard. My friend Ken says that he likes the Portaball because it 'gets out of the way.' That is, when you're looking through the Portaball on a great night, this easy-to-use telescope feels like it isn't even there; instead you're cruising through space with an almost magical ability to see astronomical wonders...