Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Mirror grinding question

Started by Grumpy_one, 04/25/2004 02:51PM
Posted 04/25/2004 02:51PM Opening Post
I'm in the rough grinding process of my 12.5 (60 grit). I am one inch from the edge. When I check the f ratio I get about a f6.3-6.9. I am using 2 methods. Sun check I get 67 inches, which calculates to f6.3, when I do a sagitta check, I get about f6.9 [F = r²/(4D)], D=. 095 r=5.25 (I’m only calculating the part of the mirror that has been ground, approx 10.5) which comes out to f6.9. My question is, when I go to parabolize, does the f ratio change? I want about f7-f8. I was told to go the depth of a dime and a penny (.110). Do I keep grinding with the 60 with the MOT until I get the .110? If I do, I’m afraid the f ratio will be to fast. My next class is Tuesday night, I was wanting to keep up with the 6-10 inch mirrors that are done with the rough grinding. I elected to do some grinding outside the class. I don’t want to have to go back and correct any errors so I’m asking the experts here. I am also using a 10 inch tool. Don't know if that is going to make any difference. Thanks, DaveT

NOTE: I posted this yesterday in the telescope making forum, no responses yet, but I think I will just wait until I go back to class on Tuesday to see what the instructor has to say. Besides, I used the last of the 60 grit I had. But with all the mirror talk here lately, I would like to get an opinion from some of the experts here. Ed? Thanks again, DaveT
Posted 04/25/2004 03:44PM #1
David,

The best way to get the curve out to the edge and slow the focal ratio down is to flip things over tool on top. Continue to work the entire mirror surface though so you don't end up with two different radii. Best of luck and clear skies.

Bill
Posted 04/26/2004 12:25AM #2
Dave, parabolizing will not alter the focal ratio significantly. Once you're well into fine grinding, say at around 500 grit size, it's pretty difficult to change the FL by much. Even harder when polishing. OTOH, in the early stages of fine grinding, you may see the FL move significantly. This can happen if your figure is not spherical, which it often is not at the end of rough grinding. If the mirror is hyperbolic (typical) at that stage, you may see the FL lengthen as the surfaces come into better contact (i.e., more spherical) during fine grinding.

The bottom line is that you want to get the FL as close as possible with your most coarse grit size. The finer the grit, the harder it is to move the FL.

Happy grinding,
Doug Scobel