Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Mount and Tripod

Started by pbunn, 06/17/2003 12:46PM
Posted 06/17/2003 12:46PM Opening Post
I have been out of astronomy for several years but still have an 8" dobsonian scope and a fair selection of eyepieces. I have been looking at the Mead and similiar 4-5" refractors with some interest. My past experience with EQ mounts and tripods has been poor. Are the newer mounts used by Mead and Celestion sturdy enough for CCD and Film photography? I'd like to get a decent mount with a lower cost scope and move up to a better OTA later. Is this a bad idea and does someone have a suggestion on a good mount. (I am not ready to spend for a Losmandy at this time)
Posted 06/18/2003 05:50AM #1
My limited experience is that inexpensive Meade eq mounts are an exercise in frustration. I used to have a really cheap Meade eq mount that came with a 1980s Schmidt-Newtonian; it literally fell apart. I currently use an LXD300 mount; the head is ok but the aluminum tripod is a catastrophe. I ordered a motor drive which was dead on arrival. I replaced the tripod with a Vixen pier, which is much better. Even so, it's only passable for visual observing with a small refractor or 8" SCT; forget imaging, no matter what the Meade ads ("all most amateurs will ever need") say.

My only other experience with Meade mounts is having observed through a fork-mounted LX200 at a couple of star parties. The mount, with a big steel tripod, is stable, but it's not low-cost.

I have a Vixen GP-DX on order. At first I ordered a Synta HEQ-5, but decided to change my order after reading several negative reports of a similar mount, the EQ6, on sci.astro.amateur. It seems to be the consensus on Astromart, Cloudy Nights, and sci.astro.amateur that the GP is about the entry-level for a stable imaging platform for small scopes. You get what you pay for when it comes to eq mounts.
Posted 03/30/2004 10:44AM #2
Personally, I would avoid the temptation of entering the refractor world unless you plan to financially commit to an APO versus an Achro. I don't thing that you won't see any thing better with an Achro than what you could see in your 8" Dob. My first scope was a C102 HD Celestron on a CG-4 GEM. The color on lunar/planetary viewing bothered me and the GEM with the cheap aluminum legs drove me crazy. For DSOs the 8" of your dob will blow away anything a 4-5" refractor can pull in.

I nevertheless continued down the refractor road and got an 4" APO and a Losmandy GM-8...man, what a difference! The losmandy GM8, IMHO is the entry level GEM to get. The cost was staggering however and I found myself wasting precious viewing time setting up and especially tearing down and storing the GEM. (when it dews up in Fla, it really dews up) I have since went the way of a Giro GR-2 Alt-Az mount on a sturdy tripod.

The lesson to this is, unless you really plan to seriously photo/image (some swear by the Tak GEMs) or you really like pinpoint sharp contrasty images that a smaller aperture APO will render, save the money and get a Starmaster 11" f5.4 ELT. With the Zambuto mirror it will beat any APO in the 4-5" category.

Sorry for the rambling, but I thought you'd like to know from a strictly visual guy.

Regards, Owen