My New scope?

Started by fblue, 06/13/2005 07:07PM
Posted 06/13/2005 07:07PM Opening Post
Well, it looks like there could be problems with the building of my new scope. sad I am now intertaining other potential scopes.
One of those I am looking at is the Starsplitter II. I can buy one of those without optics and it is already setup for the ZOC 10" F/6.
Question is this. How many of you have now or have owned a Starsplitter and how did you like it?
Thanks for any input you might give.

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 06/13/2005 07:23PM #1
I can't comment on their scopes as I don't have any experience with them but a positive feature in your situation is the fact that they are relatively local to Southern California so shipping and/or problems may be more easily solved.
Posted 06/13/2005 08:09PM | Edited 06/13/2005 08:18PM #2
Floyd I own a Starsplitter dob. I bought it used from a local member about four years ago. It is a 12.5" f/6 truss scope and was built (I think) around 1997. Unfortunately, I have no experience with other commercially built scopes and cannot make comparative statements.

The mirror box is quite large. In fact it dwarfed a Discovery 12.5 f/5 that was nearby once. I have had people say they thought it was a 15" scope. The wood is quite thick, and with a large mirror box, it is very heavy. I am guessing that the mirror box with mirror weighs about 60-65 pounds. I keep the scope stored at our club's observatory and I am gald of that because I live on a third floor flat. I have carried that beast up the stairs twice...and that's enough.

There is a small hole (1/2") in the backside of the mirror box that has a metal insert with threads. The scope comes with a 5 pound (approx.) weight on a threaded shaft. You can thread this weight into the hole in the back of the mirror box if more weight is required from adding finders etc. on the upper cage. I have never used this, but I thought it was a pretty good idea.

However, I believe the mass of the scope contributes to truly wondrous movement and balance. As an f/6 it has long truss poles. I have no trouble changing from a 22mm Nagler to a 9mm ortho and the balance and movement never know the difference. On a few occasions I have had the power up over 500x while viewing planets. I can honestly say that at that power, the movement can be accomplished with a thumb and forefinger. The movement is very smooth and there is no backlash at all.

It sets up and takes down very easily and requires no tools. The large mirror box has allowed me to install a couple 90mm fans to blow across the mirror face and stay tucked out of the way. I have not encountered any feature or aspect of the scope where I have thought "I would not have that on my next scope", or "I want to change that". Again, I must say, I have not used any other commercial scope, so there may be better ways of doing things and I am just unaware of them.

Tom Trusock over on Cloudy Nights owns (or owned) a 15" and he may be able to make some additional comments. I believe that Phil Harrington (on Talking Telescopes) owns an 18 or a 20. There is not a lot of available information about this line of scopes. If I was up-sizing, I would not hesitate to acquire another scope from Starsplitter.

Gary Weber



Attached Image:

Lucifigus's attachment for post 93031
Posted 06/13/2005 10:32PM #3
I want everyone to understand that this thread is not about Starstructure or Michael Zammit, but about my wanting information concerning the Starsplitter.
I in no way intended this thread to reflect upon Michael, who is a great guy, or his company which is an excellent manufacturer of scopes.
My intention is to gain some information about alternative manufacturers for my scope. This is so that I might meet my own requirements for a scope by a specific time.
Thank you for understanding.

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 06/13/2005 11:37PM #4
Hey Floyd,
I do have a Starsplitter scope (12.5" f/6), that I purchased new in 2001. I've got to say that I have been very happy with that scope. It is NOT Obsession or Starmaster build quality, but it is a very well built scope, with very smooth motions, and very little in the way of backlash until you get into very high magnifications (say 500+, and then very little backlash).
Pros: As every one has said--big, solid, and heavy.
Cons: Big, solid, and heavy.
If you do decide to order a new structure from Starsplitter, know that dealing with them is not like dealing with Starmaster or Obsession in terms of communications. I had to leave a number of phone messages before they got back to me, several times. When the scope did arrive it came without counterweights, and with the wrong size light shield for the truss poles.
All in all, I am finally very happy with the scope that was built for me.
Larry Seguin
Taos, New Mexico
Ps: Funny how there's just not a lot of buzz out on these scopes, isn't it?
Posted 06/14/2005 05:43AM #5
If it doesn't have to be truss, and you have a large budget, maybe one of the high tech Dobs:

Compact Precision Telescope (retractible OTA, foldable mount, world-class mirror cell)

Infinity Telescopes Uti (carbon fiber, extremely compact and transportable)

Plettstone (three-pole, Albert Highe design)

I have looked through a CPT with Royce 10". As for the Starsplitter -- I have the mirrorless body of a Compact II. It seems pretty nice except for the old style "pie mold" mirror cell. The sling mirror cell shown on Starsplitter site looks much better, but the extremely low price of the cell makes me worry a bit. My point is to shop for a mirror cell first -- it defines the maker....

Or buy a DAR Astro cell and Orion XTi, replace the Orion mirror/cell/focuser.

Just some random thoughts smile

-- William
Posted 06/14/2005 10:30PM #6
Well, Floyd, if you don't mind my saying so, I think that like many hobbyists, you are a perfectionist, or you wouldn't have traded your old scope for a SM 14.5 and you wouldn't have jumped at the chance to buy a ZOC 10 mirror. Indeed, that is how you got involved with starstructure in the first place.
So, I infer that you won't be happy with less than a superb scope. I would drop Starsplitter from consideration because of your communication problems, and because the scopes seem to be relatively heavy.
I agree with the suggestions of a previous poster: I recommend considering Compact Precision Telescopes. Mark Wagner will sell you a CPT in the 10 inch size which will fit your mirror perfectly. I own one at the Shingletown Star Party last year,and it is a great soope and Mark is excellent to deal with.
Or you could see if Michelle Stone of Plettstone telescopes would make you a 10 inch for your mirror using Albert Highe's design. I have seen her scopes and have talkded with her and I am impressed.
Starbuckets is another possibility. An acquaintance has the 6 inch model and likes it a lot.
There may be other possibilities as well. Good luck with your choice and let us know how it works out.
Bill Meyers