Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Orion 100 ED - Initial Evaluation

Started by Barry Simon, 08/14/2004 05:13PM
Posted 08/14/2004 05:13PM | Edited 08/14/2004 05:15PM Opening Post
Ok, you asked for it! You want it! (Drum roll). Well you got it, here it is -

However let me first stress how bad this scope's focuser is.
This focuser is bad. That is spelled B A D, with a double capital B! No manner of adjustment (and I spent considerable time trying to improve this focuser) could really improve it. Focusing in and out revealed areas along the travel of the focusing tube were much tighter than others. When the point is reached where the drawtube is almost all the way in with about 3/4" or so to go, it just goes completely loose and the focusing knobs do nothing. If all the way in, an upward tilt to the tube will have it drop down the 3/4" until it will work crudely. I have come to the conclusion that this particular focuser is worthless. I will be requesting a replacement. Hopefully a replacement will be better and without a scuffed tensioner knob (which does not allow for total tightening for photography anyway).

As I said before, the rest of this tube assembly is screaming for a better focuser, either a FeatherTouch or perhaps a Williams crayford.

Here is my optical evaluation.

We had a front come thru, this cool front is very unusual for mid-August in Louisiana. This gave us early October weather which started Thursday and will continue for the next few days. We have not had pristine blue skies like this since early May.

I did not pull my toys out until after midnight. So all testing was on the 14th. The Orion ED 100 mates well with the TeleVue clamshell that is available separately for the TV 102. I mounted the scope on a TV Gibraltar mount. First focused image was the star Vega. No discernable color halo around Vega. Inside of focus gave me nice concentric bullseye type circles (see image below) and I was happy with that. Outside of focus was not so definitive. Sky was unsettled as evidenced by all the swimming I could see in the out of focus image.

The Orion 100 ED could not split the Double-Double with either a 24 mm (37.5x) or 19 mm Panoptics (suspected in this one at 47x). It was a clean and easy split at 128x with a 7 mm Nagler. Note that I repeated this with the Vixen 102 and had the same results. With the Vixen the magnifications with these 3 eyepieces are 42x, 53x and 143x. I suspect that with better seeing I would be able to split the Double-Double with the 19 mm Panoptic with both scopes. I at one time had an excellent Sears Discoverer 76 mm f/16 refractor. It had great optics and could routinely split the Double-Double with a 28.7 mm RKE eyepiece (42x).

Initially I thought my timing was poor in that I had no good chromatic targets (Sirius, Venus or the lunar limb). I attributed the lack of a blue halo with Vega to the fact that it is not really seen that well, even with an achromat. This proved to be wrong when I pulled out the University Optics 80 mm f/6.25 and looked at the same target. Oh yeah! I remember, there really is more than enough chromatic aberration on bright stars like Vega with an achromat. The Vixen 102 came out next and once again our "Contact" star was Vega. The bright blue halo was unavoidable and unmistakable. Clear as day. There really is something to be said about the Orion ED, it really does suppress color. Looks like a keeper! Now to solve the focuser problem.

I also had some time to look at the Double Cluster, Pleiades and gamma Andromeda. They all looked great! I did not have the time or the stamina to hang around for a star test on Sirius or M-42 in Orion.

I will not be retesting the 100 ED from the country tonight. Weapons of choice will be a Tahakhashi FCT 76 since I will be doing some solar observing later this afternoon, and Miyauchi 20x100 binoculars. I will use the scope to shoot some more images of Vega for comparison purposes.

Let me know if there are questions.

Barry Simon


Attached Image:

Barry Simon's attachment for post 18083
Posted 08/15/2004 04:45AM #1
Thanks for the report!
It looks like the Orion has some undercorrections compare with other scopes.

Posted 08/15/2004 03:30PM #2
Nicely done Report Barry, thank you!


Ivan
smile

Ivan Gastaldo 8)
Coconut Creek, FL

Ivan's Observatory
Lat 26N 16' 48" Long 80W 10' 48"
[COLOR="Red"]Personal Website:[/COLOR] http://www.ivangastaldo.com

CCD Imaging and Processing/Deep Sky - Moderator
I like to complain about everything - Moderator
Posted 08/18/2004 01:36AM #3
Barry,

Given that the focuser is B A D. Does it look like you could replace the Orion focuser with a quality unit like a feathertouch?

Larry