Pier vs tripod

Started by Steven lynn, 07/09/2005 11:54PM
Posted 07/09/2005 11:54PM Opening Post
In my 10+ years of playing with telescopes I've only used tripods. I've never seen a simple comparison between the benefits and downsides of piers vs tripods.

I can understand the benefits of a pier in a permanent installation, but any comments comparing the two for portable equipment? The major point of course is stability, but there are all those other issues. Ergonomics, weight, hassle factor, ect. Is one generally superior to the other?

For example, I have kinda adapted to having the legs in the way. Are the feet of a tripod just a similar annoyance or in practice a great relief to not have legs in the way?

Current scopes: TV-85 on Vixen GP-very stable, Orange Tube C8 on the original tripod, 2-3 second vibration die down time.

The only thing wrong with censorship is [deleted].

Posted 07/10/2005 04:14PM #1
Steven Lynn said:

In my 10+ years of playing with telescopes I've only used tripods. I've never seen a simple comparison between the benefits and downsides of piers vs tripods.

I can understand the benefits of a pier in a permanent installation, but any comments comparing the two for portable equipment? The major point of course is stability, but there are all those other issues. Ergonomics, weight, hassle factor, ect. Is one generally superior to the other?

For example, I have kinda adapted to having the legs in the way. Are the feet of a tripod just a similar annoyance or in practice a great relief to not have legs in the way?

Current scopes: TV-85 on Vixen GP-very stable, Orange Tube C8 on the original tripod, 2-3 second vibration die down time.

I'm not sure my comparison can be applied across the board, but here are some observations.

The pier I've used is an Advanced Telescope Systems pier that's used with an AP900gto mount a friend owns.

It's rock solid - at least as good as any tripod I've used.
I suspect this is because while the legs are shorter, they're quite substantial. It's also machined to close tolerances.

The big advantage I notice with this pier is the system for leveling - Each leg has a bolt with knurls you can twist with your hand to tweak the angle (and hence the height) of the leg. It's much easier than adjusting the lengths of individual legs on a massive tripod.

I can't give you a weight comparison as I've never tried a tripod for a similarly sized mount.

But my friend can set up his pier in less time than it takes me to assemble and level my G11 tripod.

My G11 tripod is also rock solid. But the pier is more convenient if you don't mind lifting the entire weight at once.

My friend is getting a Particle Wave Technologies pier for his next scope that will use an AP 1200 mount.


Posted 07/10/2005 05:47PM #2
Steven,

I have an EM-200 and use the tripod legs with it. I am about to order a Tak portable pier for home use and keep the tripod legs for field use. IMO--a permanent pier definitely has advantages over a tripod for a permanent installation, that being it lends itself better for a rigid permanent attachment to the ground. It is much different comparing portable piers to tripods. I believe tripods, because of their design are generally as stable as portable piers. This, of course, assumes you are comparing a beefy tripod with a beefy portable pier. Tripods generally collapse easier, are more easily stored and transported and usually weigh less than a comparably sized pier. However, a portable pier does make for a nice semi-permanent installation. I have an observing pad where I intend to use my portable pier. It will be nice to use it for imaging and not be as concerned with kicking the tripod legs in the dark. It will also allow, IMO, a bit of a cleaner way to manage various cords an cables.

Of coures this my opinion, but I would say if you have a permanent installation a permanent pier is the best solution. If you have a semi-permanent (almost always use the scope at the same location) a portable pier can make great sense, and if you generally travel to your observing site, the tripod cannot be beat for portability.

Randy

Randy Roy
Posted 07/12/2005 02:16AM #3
Thanks for all your comments.

The only thing wrong with censorship is [deleted].