Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Premium 2" ep

Started by tomhole, 01/20/2004 02:09AM
Posted 01/20/2004 02:09AM Opening Post
I posted this on the ep forum as well, but I wanted to poll the larger crowd that hangs out over here.

I am in the market for a nice 2" widefield ocular. I will use it as a vista ep to provide me with a max TFOV (or close) for my 11" f/5.4 Starmaster. I don't wear glasses. Not young, not old (I guess they call that middle-aged wink. Heavy is actually good in my case as I have the Starmaster balanced for about 2.2 lbs of binoviewer and ep's. I can get away with .5 lbs either side of that without having to rebalance, which is preferred. Cost is a consideration in the bang for the buck sense. If it costs $600, I want $600 in performance. If I can get 95% at 1/2 that price, then I'm happy. Used is my primary target.

I am a binoviewer nut, so the best I can do right now is .75 deg TFOV with the 24 Pans in the binoviewers.

So, here's my list and I'm open for more suggestions:

EP: mag, TFOV, exit pupil, weight, price

41mm Pan: 37x 1.74 deg, 7.5mm, 2.1 lbs, $495
35mm Pan: 44x, 1.5deg, 6.4mm, 1.6 lbs, $365
31mm Nagler: 49x, 1.6 deg, 5.7mm, 2.2 lbs, $620
32mm UO MK80: 48x, 1.6 deg, 5.9mm, 1.2lbs ish, $295

Anything else? A guy in my club has the 32mm UO MK80 and our club has a 31 Nagler, so as soon as the weather breaks I plan to make a comparison between them. The UO is half the price and my man reports good performance in his f/5 Portaball. But until then, I want to see if the list needs to get bigger.

All inputs are encouraged and welcome.

Clear skies,

Tom
Posted 01/20/2004 02:18AM #1
31mm Nagler is the best of all the EPs you have listed. I have used each of these and the Nagler wins.
The Pan 41mm is a close but no cigar 2nd.
35mm Pan is a close 3rd.
It is the crisp, bright, clear image that makes the 31mm the winner.
I bought the 31mm Nagler myself, so I put my money where my mouth was. :^)
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 01/20/2004 02:58AM #2
Tom,

I have the 16" Starmaster and use the Paracorr for an effective F4.9. The 26 Nagler is the best eyepiece I've used in the scope (balancing best eye relief for the largest FOV for my eyes for my scope's focal ratio). The 31 is magnificent, but from a dark site I frequent, I was able to view the Horsehead recently with the 26mm Nagler, but not the 31mm Nagler. I believe the difference was primarily the more favorable exit pupil of the 26mm with my scope as well as the increase contrast due to the slightly shorter focal length. BTW, I was able to see it with the 22 Nagler, 24 Panoptic and 17 Nagler. I sold the 31mm and kept the rest. Had my scope been an F6 or greater instead, I have no doubt the 31mm would be a killer ep.

It sure would be great if you could do some comparisons before committing funds.

Randy

Randy Roy
Posted 01/20/2004 03:14AM #3
I would go with the 31 Nagler. I have yet to see a eyepiece in this range beat it.
Posted 01/21/2004 01:46AM #4
Thanks to everyone so far.

I do feel kinda silly in that I already have a pretty good widefield ep that can fill in on the tougher targets and provide a 1 deg TFOV. Actually, I have 2 of them, the 24 Pan. That will work very well if I run into a dim target that a 30mm+ ep can't handle. That brings me back to a single ep choice for max TFOV. That simplifies things. I'm leaning towards the 31 Nagler, 32 UO MK80 and 35 Pan. I think the 40mm series are out because of my mag 4 skies. Luckily, I can try all of these out in my club. Life is good.

Clear skies,

TOm