Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Question about Airy Disk on AR6

Started by power_overwhelming, 09/03/2003 02:16PM
Posted 09/03/2003 02:16PM Opening Post
Hi I have a Meade AR6 and have a question about Airy Disks. The collimation on my scope is perfect from what I can tell on both sides of focus. But when I have a bright star in focus at high power(more then 200x) I see about 4 Airy Disks around it. The “problem” that I see is that they are significantly brighter on one side then the other. Star itself is a perfect little orb very similar to an APO but not quite as perfect. I know this is not the diagonal as I have tried to remove it and get the same thing. Also at very high powers the airy disk’s become quite large and noticeable, should they be so prominent? Any thoughts about the uneven brightness? Thanks.
Posted 09/03/2003 02:31PM #1
No obvious ideas from me...have you eliminated the eyepiece as the cause? Thomas Back has provided an excellent star test procedure at:

http://voltaire.csun.edu/tmb/tmb4.html

As he suggests, use filters to isolate chromatic and sphero-chromatic aberrations. I have seen such aberrations in my Meade AR5 (127mm f/9.3) when CCD imaging Mars, and would expect a more pronounced error in the 150mm f/8 optic.

My old Celestron (Synta) CR150 did not have a "perfect" intra and extra focal pattern, but performance was still excellent for an achro doublet.
Posted 09/03/2003 02:50PM #2
Another possibility is that the two lens elements in the achromat could be *slightly* out of alignment with each other, making perfect collimation impossible. This can happen easily in refractors with plastic cells if the lens housing is loose or cross-threaded.
Posted 09/03/2003 02:53PM #3
Hmmm...usually when I hear about airy discs being brighter on one one side then the other I'm thinking coma...but I wouldn't expect that in a f/8 refractrr unless the lens cell wasn't squared