Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Refiguring versus buying new?

Started by toml, 08/21/2003 05:05AM
Posted 08/21/2003 05:05AM Opening Post
Okay here's my dilemma: Buy a Coulter 13.1" and have an Optical genius like Steve Swayze refigure it to his standards of perfection for a little more than half the price of a new mirror figured by the afformentioned optician.

True the all-new mirror will be based on pyrex, but as far as final PTV and smoothness...is there an appreciable (subjective) or testable (objective) difference between the two finished surfaces?

Maybe that's an obvious "NO" but if it is, I don't know that as I'm still quite a novice and certainly have no experience with having mirrors refigured and resurfaced.

Posted 08/21/2003 06:13AM #1
Use of Pyrex aids in the polishing and figuring process timeline because heat has less of an impact on dimensional stability. Plate glass is OK as a substrate, just takes longer to figure waiting for it to cool. Pyrex, quartz, or other exotic substrates offer nice-to-have but not overwelming thermal advantages for a Dob application.

It could be argued that an investment in a high Strehl first surface will be more compromised thermally with plate glass. So your challenge will be thermal.

Will Steve refigure Coulter optics as a regular service?
Posted 08/21/2003 07:08AM #2
One hazard of re-figuring is that you don't really know
alot about the quality of the glass. You are taking a
gamble that it was properly annealed, etc. I had a
second hand mirror re-figured to a very nice spec,
but it warped during aluminizing and I ended up with
a very expensive 5/8 wave mirror (aka doorstop).
Apparently the glass blank was never annealed properly.
Having lived and learned, I would advise to start
with a top-notch glass; let the "optical genius" pick
the glass. Besides less risk, he'll also be more
familiar with working the material.