Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Which Would You Choose?

Started by Dave Mitsky, 08/29/2004 06:21AM
Posted 08/29/2004 06:21AM | Edited 08/29/2004 06:24AM Opening Post
In order to prove a point to someone who badly needs it done I'd like to pose the following question:

For visual use only which is the better deep-sky (and the emphasis in on deep-sky) telescope, a 127mm f/12.1 Maksutov-Cassegrain or a 10 inch Newtonian Dob that is currently selling for about the same price?

Let me make it clear that I believe that I know a thing or two about the capabilities of both instruments and am not inquiring about a personal purchase. I already own nine telescopes. :-) I merely want to gather the opinions of other observers.

Dave Mitsky

Chance favors the prepared mind.

De gustibus non est disputandum.
Posted 08/29/2004 08:31AM #1
Dave, I own 9 telescopes too! Anyway, I once got the chance to prove a point similar to this first hand at a dark sky star party. A fellow there believed a 4 inch apo. refractor was the only way to go. (I think he was saving his money for one.) At the time I had both my 4 inch Genesis SDF refractor and my 8 inch f/6 Dob set up. I aimed both scopes at the same deep sky object (M11) and invited him to compare the views. He was shocked at the difference of the views these two scopes provided. The 8 inch blew away the 4 inch and this was against a scope which is optimized for deep sky viewing with its f/5.4 flat field of view. In this case the fellow was enlightened to buy a bigger reflector and save some serious money as well. In a contest verses a Mak Cas its even less of a contest for deep sky with its narrower field of view. Convince your friend to buy the Dob and maybe later in the future get the Mak Cas. This is how we ended up with 9 scopes each - there is no scope that can do it all. (Although I hate to admit it but it I'm sure it takes LESS than 9 scopes to do it all!) Take care, Dave Sewell
Posted 08/29/2004 10:27AM #2
hi,

for those of us who are buying our first scope a 10" dob is an excellent choice.

clear skeis,

Larry Citro
Posted 08/29/2004 12:32PM #3
Dave,

The obvious answer is the larger aperture, but I have to ask you whether you are really trying to help this guy or "defend your honor" or what? I've seen this posted on several groups now which makes it appear a little over the top to me. If you are using this method to get the message to the guy, I doubt that he will get it.

Your previous postings and contributions prove that you are a credible and knowledgeable amateur astronomer.

Sometimes, knowing you are right should be enough.

Randy

Randy Roy
Posted 08/29/2004 07:15PM #4
I just went through a similar excercise. I was using a 5" f/6 EQ mounted Mak-Newt as my quick look scope. This is fine for planets and the moon, but for deep sky it was not satisfactory for me. For short sessions, I usually just look at familiar, brighter Messier objects. My other scopes are 15" dob and 10" EQ-mounted SCT. They are both fully assembled and can be rolled out, but their size made them unsuitable for 1/2 to 1 hour session, especially when it's windy. I need the ability to put the scope in a part of my property that is protected from our ever-present high desert spring and summer wind.

My solution was to take advantage of Orion's sale on their XT dob in July and bought a 8" f/6 dob. I can park the dob anywhere out of the wind and point it at the part of the sky that's visible. Now I have a quick look scope that satisfies my deep sky cravings. The view of the Messier objects in the 8" dob is far more satisfying than in my 5" MN.

A 10" dob it will be so much better on deep sky that a 5" at the cost of a little more weight and bulk. But these thing are somewhat relative anyway. What's a pain for one person is no big deal for another. Some people are satisfied with views of deep sky with 4-5" scopes, some require more aperture.


Nat

Santa Fe
Posted 08/29/2004 11:23PM #5
For DSOs aperture "rules", no question about that...


Ivan
smile

Ivan Gastaldo 8)
Coconut Creek, FL

Ivan's Observatory
Lat 26N 16' 48" Long 80W 10' 48"
[COLOR="Red"]Personal Website:[/COLOR] http://www.ivangastaldo.com

CCD Imaging and Processing/Deep Sky - Moderator
I like to complain about everything - Moderator
Posted 08/31/2004 06:12AM | Edited 08/31/2004 06:19AM #6
Hi Dave,

I usually agree with all the other comments already posted, but I just had an interesting experience in the Idaho mountains 2 weekends ago with my Sky90 and a 10" older Coulter dob. These sizes aren't exactly what you were looking for, but somewhat similar I think. I had both scopes side by side running about the same magnification of 40X. Sky with partial moon below the horizon was only giving about a mag 6.

The collimation on the dob was a little off, but at such a low power, stars were still reasonably sharp, and it was not noticeably bad. I looked at all the usual bright Sagittarius objects as well as the Ring, and Dumbell. When I did my side by side comparison, the 10" was of course always giving a brighter image, but the Sky90 was just so sharp that delicate wispy details seemed to show up in the Sky90 while the Dob would just be a brighter less detailed image. My family had all gone to bed, as well as my dad, but my mom came out around 11pm to see what I was up to. After looking at a few of the clusters and nebulas in the Teapot, she preferred the Sky90 as the stars were just small pinpoints and the finer (dimmer) nebulosity was more finely detailed.

It could be the dob's coatings were too old, although a quick look down the tube at the mirror showed no obvious problems. Collimation is always an issue with short F-ratio dobs, and this one could use a tweek. I was using an Ultima ep. on the Dob, which may not have been the best for such a short F-ratio. Also, some Coulter dobs were just not that good, this could be one of them, but at such a low power, I would not think a 1/4 wave mirror would harm the system that much at 40X . Lots of potential optical variables here.

The conclusion for me, was that a dob needs a certain amount of care and feeding such as collimation, and re-coating, while the APO is always at peak performance. Also with low end dobs, some optical quality issues can come up. Although most of the newer scopes seem to be fine in that regard.

At first it would seem the Dob would be the easy answer, but factoring in some of these issues can sometimes make the decision more interesting.

The 5” f12.1 Mak is a different scope than a f5.5 Sky90, so my recent comparison may be a little off topic, but some of the points may still apply.

David Simons


Attached Image:

David Simons's attachment for post 82578

David Simons