Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Why Bother With Super Planetary EP's ??

Started by DarthVader, 10/14/2004 11:23PM
Posted 10/14/2004 11:23PM | Edited 10/14/2004 11:25PM Opening Post
I am just curious about the concept of "super planetary" EP's. There has been a great deal of hype surrounding some that have hit the market, or are destined to hit the market. Personally, I don't see all the hype surronding the mimimal benefits that one of these EP's might deliver over other available brands. For instance, in one recent yahoo group discussion on EP's Televue (Al and David Nagler) posted this when questioned if they had considered a super EP for planets:

"There seems to be a myth that you must have a small field to get optimum sharpness. All Tele Vue eyepieces are diffraction limited at center, even for fast scopes. Our philosophy has always been to retain that sharpness over the widest possible fields. However, contrast and light throughput are enhanced by simple designs. Our 4-element Plossls, with 4-air/glass surfaces were measured as 97% transmissive by Sky and Telescope. It's just fine if other manufacturers can eke out a bit more transmission with fewer surfaces, at the expense of reduced field, reduced eye-relief, reduced edge field correction for users who can accept that. It's just not for us, since we feel our patented Plossls do a fine job on planets."

Further when questioned if the statement above held true about their other EP lines like the Radians, Naglers, and Panoptics they responded:

The 11mm Nagler, 10mm Radian and 11mm Plossl are equally sharp for planetary viewing. We compared them again, and found that in no case could we see more detail in the Plossl. However, given four more air-glass surfaces plus higher index glasses in the Nagler, Radian and Panoptics, the Plossl was confirmed very slightly whiter. The 97% Plossl transmission in the S&T test report was not subjectively brighter than the estimated 94% transmission measured in the other eyepieces. Our feeling is that with the equal perception of contrast, comfortable eye-relief and dramatic field of view outweigh the very slight extra whiteness of the Plossl. Purists may disagree(to a small degree), but that's why we have more than one eyepiece type in our offerings.

Is there anyone out there that can make a strong argument for the minimal gain of a Super Planetary EP over the already high quality and high transmission rate EP's like the ones that Televue and Pentax are bringing to the table?



Posted 10/14/2004 11:37PM #1

I do not have a lot of experience in observing. I have used 6 and 4mm radians and a 5mm TMB. I do find that the image is consistently brighter (by just a bit) in the TMB than either radian. This only comes into effect when I observe globular clusters or faint doubles. On planets the image appeared cleaner with the TMB.

I was no blinded as to which eyepiece I was using and my observation might be influenced by how I expected each EP to perform. The differences were slight but IMO perceived.

howard
Posted 10/14/2004 11:57PM #2
You can judge the coatings and internal scatter of almost any eyepiece quite easily yourself. Most coatings are not ideal when applied to multiple elements, and although when properly applied, they may indeed produce good results, all too often coatings in production fall far short of their peak performance. Here is a way to see what you have in any particular eyepiece. I call it the sidewalk test: http://voltaire.csun.edu/roland/coating.html

The test is simple, and instantly shows how much light is scattered internally in an eypiece. Light from the sky is allowed to flood the optics and proceed through to the black cover. Any light that bounces around the optics and comes back to your eye is not only lost to the image, but also contributes to lowering the overall contrast. A "Super Planetary eyepiece" will have few scattering elements and few air-glass surfaces to scatter, reflect and absorb light. Therefore the image will have more contrast inherently.

Roland Christen
Posted 10/15/2004 12:25AM #3
Paul,

I used Pentax XLs for many years and now the Pentax XWs along with a set of Pentax SMC .965 orthos for most of my observing.

On Mars last summer and on Saturn last week, to my eyes, the improvement in contrast and surface detail is definitely superior with the orthos. They are my standard planetary eps. I would even say that on Mars the improvement was significantly better and readily apparent with the orthos over the XLs.

My .02 worth,
Jay
Posted 10/15/2004 02:46AM #4
I have Pentax XLs, Pentax XWs, Pentax Ortho, and several TMBs.

I find that there are usually one or two features on the moon or planet that I DO NOT SEE until I use the TMB or the Pentax ortho. Once I see the feature, I can find it in any eyepiece but I do not see it until I hit it with the right eyepiece. Most of the time, the eyepieces that I have this happen with are the TMBs (Once in a while, the ortho).

This happens on the Moon and planets. THe effect is less on deep fuzzies and I have noticed it on my 8" SCT, 10" Dob, and my 4.5" Apo.
,
Posted 10/15/2004 03:56PM #5

I would like to add some of my thoughts on this subject. I think the new TMB and AP eyepieces are the best for planetary viewing. Plossl and Ortho eyepieces have a lot more air to glass surfaces than these new eyepieces. The Plossl's have such bad eye relief that they are hard to find in powers greater than 8mm. I will say that I think eye relief is not as big a deal as some would make it. A friend of mine wears glasses and has no problem viewing with my 4mm TMB with his glasses on. The trick is don't try to shove your eye into the eyepiece. Planets are small and if you keep them in the center of the eyepiece you can back off the eyepiece and still see the planet just fine. Its like watching a movie, how many of you sit in the front row? Or do you tend to sit back a ways. Also with high powers you don't need to have your glasses on anyway, so take them off. Now a lot of people think these new eyepieces cost to much. They don't think they are that much better than the Ortho's and Plossl's. But when you have a night that is a 10, or you are trying to get that last little bit of detail out of a planet these eyepieces will help. Now what I'm trying to do is when Jupiter is back up high I want to try and see detail in one of its moons. I haven't done it yet, but I bet when I do there will be a TMB or AP eyepiece in my scope. I feel that some of the best minds in the field are now making planetary eyepieces. If they felt the Orthos and other types were better they would use them.