Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

21 Ethos vs. ES20

Started by JEmirzian, 03/27/2010 03:00PM
Posted 03/27/2010 03:00PM Opening Post
Had an opportunity to observe with both the 21 Ethos and ES20 last night. The telescope was a 7" TMB and the majority of the target was the moon. I use a 1.00 dioptrx and made sure each corrector was perfectly rotated for maximum sharpness. Both eyepieces accept the dioptrx system.

Both eyepieces showed a hint of false color in the outer 15-20% off axis. On axis....NOTHING. The color wasn't major, but there was a slight yellow halo. A Lumicon rotating polarizer seemed to calm this down. Both eyepieces were tack sharp and I couldn't make a decision which was sharper. The only advantage of the Ethos was it had a slight bit more contrast then the ES20. If you didn't have both eyepieces to compare it wouldn't jump out at you. The owner of the 21 Ethos made the same conclusions.

The eyepieces had such a huge FOV you really had to look around in the eyepiece to take it all in. It really gave you the sense you were looking though a port hole. Awesome experience!!

So the question you have to ask yourself is the slight bit of contrast worth the extra cash? That is a decision only YOU can make. I'm going to stick with the ES20 untill I have the extra few hundred dollars. I can justify spending the money elsewhere. I will say that the 13 and 8 Ethos eyepieces I own WILL NOT get replaced with the ES line.
Posted 03/28/2010 02:13AM #1
Jay,

How does the eye relief compare between the two? Thanks.


Regards,

Mark
Posted 03/28/2010 01:30PM #2
You have the same eyepieces as I: the E8 and E13 and the ES 20. I also may upgrade to the E21 because I don't like the recessed eyelens in the ES20. It unnecessarily reduces the eye relief to the point where eyeglass wearers have difficulty. Everything else is first rate. It would be nice to hear a comparison on deep sky with a newt.
Posted 03/29/2010 04:58AM #3
Hi Jay- You say that the ES20 will accept the Dioptrx system. Will the Dioptrx actually attach positively to the EP or does it just lay on it? Thanks much.
Posted 04/20/2010 07:52PM #4
I have been observing through a friend's Ethos eyepieces at our local star parties. I own several dozen eyepieces and have been observing for more than 40 years. My current favorite EP for general viewing is the 22mm Panoptic. I was completely underwhelmed by the Ethos EP's. I didn't like the 100 degree field of view, since I have to move my head around to take it all in. When I have to move my head around to see the entire field of view, it's like looking through a tube. With a smaller field of view and a nice sharp field stop at the periphery of my vision, I forget that I'm looking through an eyepiece and get the ambience of "being there."