I've just received my first 2 filters,a Celestron UHC and OIII 2". I noticed some pin prick sized holes in the emulsion. I don't suppose this will affect the image, but I was wondering if defects like this are to be expected in lower priced filters,or should I send them back for an exchange? Thanks much.
Celestron filters
Started by dru, 08/10/2010 05:03PM
Posted 08/10/2010 05:03PM
Opening Post
Posted 08/10/2010 05:23PM
#1
Andrew Gawel said:
I've just received my first 2 filters,a Celestron UHC and OIII 2". I noticed some pin prick sized holes in the emulsion. I don't suppose this will affect the image, but I was wondering if defects like this are to be expected in lower priced filters,or should I send them back for an exchange? Thanks much.
I haven't noticed this often, but I haven't gone looking, either. It will have no effect. In my experience, the Celestron (Baader) filters perform very well.
Uncle Rod
Time on your hands?
Waste it with Uncle Rod's Astro Blog!
http://uncle-rods.blogspot.com/
Posted 08/10/2010 07:01PM
#2
I have a number of filters and have never noticed a defect in the coatings on any of them. I would not expect any either. While I agree with Rod that a pinprick or two would not affect the images, they may affect the resale value if the defects are at all noticeable. Besides, if I have paid new retail price for something, I don't feel good accepting less than I expected. If you have the option to exchange them, I would be inclined to do it. What are you going to do a year from now if you have to clean the filter and discover that the pinprick is blistered defect?
dan
dan
Posted 08/11/2010 12:55PM
#3
I've had a Celestron OIII filter for quite some time. It works very well and has allowed me to see many faint planetary and emmision nebulas. I doubt the pin holes will effect you views but if it was me I think I would exchange them. You work hard for your money and you should get what you pay for.
Andreas
Andreas
DSOs observed:
NGCs 2005, ICs 103, Other 70, Palomar GCs 6, Abell PNs 12, Herschel 400: 316.
Equipment
Celestron CPC 1100, Lunt 60mm Ha Solar Scope
Funding Member