Debating among EPs, need advice

Started by actuary616, 10/02/2009 08:26PM
Posted 10/02/2009 08:26PM Opening Post
My scope is Sky-Watcher 12" Dob. Right now, I have Nagler T5 26, and Ethos 13. I am very happy about them. Now, I am considering to acquire some high power EP. There are three approaches as below. Can you give me your 2 cents? Thank you in advance.
1. Nagler T6 9mm (167x)+T6 7mm (215x)
2. Ethos 8mm (188x)
3. Ethos 13+Antares 2" 1.6x barlow (175x)
Posted 10/12/2009 02:57PM | Edited 10/12/2009 03:05PM #1
Howdy,
I've been rolling the same scenario over in my head for months now. I happen to have a 7" Maksutov, so we're dealing with two different scopes. Because I have a small aperture and long focal length, I didn't want a Barlow in the mix. However the 13mm Ethos works well, and the Antares Barlow is good. Astro Physics make one of the best if you want to make detailed comparisons. However, your 26mm Nagler and 13mm Ethos have you off to a great start.

I use a 56mm Meade 4000 series Super Plossl, a 27mm TeleVue Panoptic and a 13mm Ethos. In my scope the Ethos gives me a little over 200X. For higher magnifications, I've found the Takahashi LE series to be an excellent eyepiece. Better than the TeleVues for light throughput, color and contrast. I have a 7.5mm Tak-LE and am waiting for a 10mm LE.

When seeing conditions are poor, having a few extra small eyepieces comes in handy. Keep in mind these have a 52 degree aparent field of view, and wider fields are very useful on a Newtonian.

If you want to save some money and have heaps of aperture to begin with, the Barlow will work very well. Using an Ethos, a Nagler or any eyepiece with a Barlow reduces the True Field Of View (TFOV) in proportion to the increase in magnification, but you'll still have much more than other EPs will yield.

There's two cents!
Have a good one!
Steve
smile
Posted 10/12/2009 08:46PM | Edited 10/12/2009 08:46PM #2
Zhuo,
If you like the 13mm Ethos and you can afford the 8mm, that seems like the obvious choice to me.
I have spent a lot of nights using little more than my 26mm T5, 13mm, and 8mm Ethos.
It is amazing on GC's, and many galaxies, M51 for example. It's also excellent for planetary use.
Better eye relief than the T6 Naglers, plus a big eye lens, and better contrast.
I use mine in 14.5" and 10" dobs mostly, similar to you.
Have fun, whatever you get. smile
Linton
Posted 10/12/2009 09:58PM #3
I would suggest that you go with option #3. The Antares 1.6x barlow costs a lot less than the 8mm Ethos, and you get just about the same mag/fov. When I owned a 13mm Ethos and a 16" Starmaster, I loved the 13mm E/Antares barlow combination. I don't know about the rest of the Ethos line, but the 13mm barlows about as well as any eyepiece that I have ever owned. FWIW, I don't typically care for barlows.

Doug
Midway, FL