Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Interesting results!!

Started by fct-150, 06/19/2014 06:52AM
Posted 06/19/2014 06:52AM Opening Post
So tonight I FINALLY got to haul-out my Galaxy Optics 18" f/4.5 aluminum dob and I cannot tell any of you how astounded I was by image contrast and sharpness wagered by what oculars I chose. For the first time in many years, complex TeleVue eyepieces simply walked all over my vintage collection; wasn't expecting this at all.

I went out with my choice defaults first; the ones I'd be playing with in the Borg, Taks, Vernonscopes, ect... Started off with a 40mm Parks plossl from the 1970s. Sharp, but it started to lose that pinpoint definition within 25 degrees of the center! So I put in my 1992 Axiom 40mm. BIG difference! The stars now focused to true "snap" pinpoints and the resolved edge was great until right around 10-degrees. So then I put in the big heavy, a 40mm Widefield circa 1988. Almost as sharp as the Axiom, but the feeling of a "flat" backdrop was readily apparent.

We're looking at the M13 and M57 back-and-forth by the way, in case yer wonderin'. Upping the power, I switched to a TV Widefield 24.5mm. Same flatness, but the resolved edges were reduced somewhat. So then I took a breath and very carefully slid the Delos 17.3mm into the Moonlite...WOW! Very "black" contrast and very "white" stars that were pinpoint for 60 of the 72 degrees offered. Absolutely whooped the Widefield. I could stare right at the ring and see definition even in my suburbia 4.2 mag skies. Same thing with M13, I could stare at it directly and see sharp points and black space. What a view.
Skies were not very steady though, so I did an ultimate test; an Ethos 13. The stars held up very sharply, but I could tell all those elements were taking a tiny toll on brightness. This, of course, was completely lost as I was wowed by the "Where's the edge of fov!" effect. Threading an OIII to the Ethos, M57 looked like Krispy Kreme donut that had sat in a dust storm....I mean, hey, the donut is gray; I'm not eating it like this, but it still looks COOL!

To finish off the night, I ended a few sights (other than these two objects of prime interest) with a look through the death weight 20mm Nag II, which aside from the Delos, gave the MOST impressively sharp view. And then for a goof off, I inserted the Ultima 80, which gave me something like 60mm eye relief and made M57 look like a star more than a planetary neb.

Good, fun. Can't wait to go south 24 miles where it is 5.7 mag skies and really test the oculars. I just couldn't believe it though. Mainly being an apochromat priss, I walked into this maiden 18 voyage with the concept that plossls and orthos would still dominate. And in truth, they now won't have a home in the big dob.


Just a few thoughts:

8) FS-152SV sitting in the office
grin Japanes super lucky zen observatory garden
:S Meade ETX-90 finder scope position
shocked Hino Optical Mizar 120SL observatory model
:C SR-4mm eyepiece with a 3x barlow in a 60mm refractor
8O Zeiss Victory 7x42 SFs
wink Having over 135 vintage oculars to play with
smile My life surrounded by wonderful friends and impeccable optics
Posted 06/19/2014 10:43AM #1
Andy Sedlacek said:

So tonight I FINALLY got to haul-out my Galaxy Optics 18" f/4.5 aluminum dob and I cannot tell any of you how astounded I was by image contrast and sharpness wagered by what oculars I chose. For the first time in many years, complex TeleVue eyepieces simply walked all over my vintage collection; wasn't expecting this at all.

I went out with my choice defaults first; the ones I'd be playing with in the Borg, Taks, Vernonscopes, ect... Started off with a 40mm Parks plossl from the 1970s. Sharp, but it started to lose that pinpoint definition within 25 degrees of the center! So I put in my 1992 Axiom 40mm. BIG difference! The stars now focused to true "snap" pinpoints and the resolved edge was great until right around 10-degrees. So then I put in the big heavy, a 40mm Widefield circa 1988. Almost as sharp as the Axiom, but the feeling of a "flat" backdrop was readily apparent.

We're looking at the M13 and M57 back-and-forth by the way, in case yer wonderin'. Upping the power, I switched to a TV Widefield 24.5mm. Same flatness, but the resolved edges were reduced somewhat. So then I took a breath and very carefully slid the Delos 17.3mm into the Moonlite...WOW! Very "black" contrast and very "white" stars that were pinpoint for 60 of the 72 degrees offered. Absolutely whooped the Widefield. I could stare right at the ring and see definition even in my suburbia 4.2 mag skies. Same thing with M13, I could stare at it directly and see sharp points and black space. What a view.
Skies were not very steady though, so I did an ultimate test; an Ethos 13. The stars held up very sharply, but I could tell all those elements were taking a tiny toll on brightness. This, of course, was completely lost as I was wowed by the "Where's the edge of fov!" effect. Threading an OIII to the Ethos, M57 looked like Krispy Kreme donut that had sat in a dust storm....I mean, hey, the donut is gray; I'm not eating it like this, but it still looks COOL!

To finish off the night, I ended a few sights (other than these two objects of prime interest) with a look through the death weight 20mm Nag II, which aside from the Delos, gave the MOST impressively sharp view. And then for a goof off, I inserted the Ultima 80, which gave me something like 60mm eye relief and made M57 look like a star more than a planetary neb.

Good, fun. Can't wait to go south 24 miles where it is 5.7 mag skies and really test the oculars. I just couldn't believe it though. Mainly being an apochromat priss, I walked into this maiden 18 voyage with the concept that plossls and orthos would still dominate. And in truth, they now won't have a home in the big dob.


Hi Andy, sounds like you'll be enjoying a lot more with the 18! For me the ol' trusty 20mm Nagler type II is what I use the most in my 18" F/5. With yours being an F/4.5 you will benefit from a Paracorr to correct for the coma. Then those stars near the edge will stay in focus.

Welcome to the world of Big Dobs!
Posted 06/19/2014 05:00PM #2
Yes sir, good glass and aperture make great evening companions.
8)

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager