Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

UWAN 28 MM Experiences?

Started by wavelandscott, 07/01/2006 09:40AM
Posted 07/01/2006 09:40AM Opening Post
Disclaimer...I'm not a particularly experienced observer and I am doubting myself a bit on what I saw...your comments/thoughts appreciated.

A group of observers I know had an opportunity to try this eyepeice a few weeks ago with 10 inch GSO (f5) Dobs and felt they were not very good...a whole laundry list of shortcomings...I was not at that observing session...

About a week ago, I tried the same eyepiece in my 12.5 inch Discovery truss Dob...other than the size and weight (it is big) I thought it was a nice performing eyepiece...I do not have a big Nagler to compare it to but from memory (I have borrowed a 31 MM Nagler in the past) I did not see (my impression of my memory) a lot of differences.

I've since gone and read the generally positive reveiws that closely relfect what i think I saw...made me feel good...

However, how do I square my experience with that of some of my observing buddies?

Can we both be right?

Again, I don't have years of experience (I do think I am proficient but not near expert) so what might cause the differences in experiences?

Same dark site...

Thanks All...

Posted 07/01/2006 04:10PM #1
Hi Scott,
A couple of possibilities here I guess. One would be that they did more critical testing for specific aberrations and problems. The other would be that they did not get a good sample of the EP.

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 07/01/2006 04:29PM #2
When I first started in this hobby, I had an eyepiece which came from an old Bausch & Lomb microscope. It was a 10x Widefield eyepiece (25mm FL). I thought that this was the most perfect eyepiece in existence, and never saw any aberrations in it. The images were crisp, clear and contrasty in all the scopes that I had at the time (a 3"F15 refractor and 8" SCT).

Now that I have been in the astronomy business for more than 30 years and seen and tested numerous eyepieces, I have a better understanding of what constitutes a good eyepiece. The old B&L Widefield is quite poor indeed. It is a simple Kellner design, and I don't know what made me think it was so great back then. It has ghosting, severe aberrations toward the edge, chromatic aberration, astigmatism, lateral color etc., and at 45 degree apparent field, it is not exactly wide field.

When you first start out in this hobby, everything is great. The longer you are at it, the crappier things become. That is the curse of this hobby sad (besides the weather).

Rolando
Posted 07/01/2006 09:25PM #3
Individual tolerance for astigmatism in ep's varies from person to person.

Thermal issues vary from 10" to 12" scopes, mirror cells, active vs passive cooling and solid tube vs truss. All of this shows up in the ep.

Anybody involved using (or not using) a Paracorr?

For high end ep's, the only real comparisons in fast scope that count, are the ones in ones own scope. This means a side by side between ep's. Or the classifieds on Astromart in combo with specific repeat targets.

Posted 07/01/2006 10:36PM #4
Sorry for the length of this...

I appreciate the comments with respect to need for objectivity and experience and I agree with those sentiments...

However, that was not really the point of my questions...

I was probably not clear enough in my original post so I will try again...

Some of the reviews found on the internet suggest that this eyepiece is a "competitor" to the Nagler line with all that this comparison implies (quality fit and finish, wide view, sharpness to edge of field)...

I have a few naglers, a pentax and panoptic a few plossls (from cheap chinese to TV) having worked my way up the food chain over time. Like many I have learned to appreciate the difference (sometimes subtle) between good, great and wow! Having said that, I am confident that there are many many other people who have a much higher "technical" and "asthetic" appreciation and understanding of what makes up a quality eyepiece. I consider myself proficient (not advanced or expert)...

Background...

Before reading any reviews on this eyepeice (at that point I was an as yet unbiased sample point), I had a chance to use it...I found it to be very comparable to a 31 MM Nagler (I do not own it but have used one a couple of times)...yes, a bit subjective in my comments but as it was a "memory" comparison the best I can do...I enjoyed the view enough that I thought it worthwhile to see what experiences other people were having with this eyepeice.

I was pleased (vanity on my part)to see that some other people whom I have some regard for found this eyepeice to be a good "competitor" to the Nagler...In this instance there are a number of objective evaluations that were performed...

I was then suprised to talk with some local observers who I sometimes view with who did not find the eyepiece to be very good at all (for a number of reasons among them edge performance and field curvature...their words not mine).

While we did view on seperate nights, it was the same observing site similar conditions with respect to the sky. The only difference I can think of (besides observers) were the scopes...I used my 12.5 inch Discovery Truss (cooled 3 hours +) and they used a 10 inch GSO tube dob (cooled 3 hours +). In neither instance was a parracorr used.

My question...

Besides "experience" of the observers involved, is there anything technically that might cause these diverse opinions?

Is there some difference between the two (f5) scopes that might account for the differences?

While I recognize that "mileage may vary" from user to user and scope to scope I am puzzled as to the vast difference in opinion...

It was exactly the same eyepeice (I mean the "same" eyepiece)...the owner looked through the eyepeice with both scopes (at different times) and was amazed at the differences...the eyepeice works well in his own scope (CAT) I agreed with him viewing through his scope myself...

What might account for the differences?

Collimation would have been accurate in both instances...I am a bit stumped on this hence my original post...

Thanks!