Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Why Rectilinear Distortion?

Started by Jud, 09/13/2007 12:11PM
Posted 09/13/2007 12:11PM | Edited 09/13/2007 12:12PM Opening Post
It is a little confusing to me why rectilinear distortion seems to have been a necessary evil in Tele Vue EPs. First, why was it accepted when it seems other designs have minimized it? Second, since I have not used such EPs in refractors or slow dobs, is it as pronounced in these scopes? There must be a benefit of RD, be it design cost, increased image quality toward the edges, or other.

Now, with the introduction of Ethos, RD seems to have been minimized. Any help in clarifying this will be appreciated.

I Yam What I Yam!
Posted 09/13/2007 01:31PM | Edited 09/13/2007 01:46PM #1
Here is a post from the Yahoo groups from Chris Lord of the Brayebrook Observatory. It is a bit technical but explains what is going on.

There are two types of eyepiece distortion, Angular Magnification
Distortion (AMD) & Rectilinear Distortion (RD). It is not possible to
correct for both simultaneously because AMD is proportional to the
tangent of the field radius and RD the field radius (expressed in
radians).

Once tangent field radius and radius in radians begin to significantly
depart (afov > 1 radian ~ 57ยบ), distortion (lack of Orthoscopy) becomes
a design issue. Astronomical eyepieces are corrected for AMD, which
typically results in +ve RD (pincussion); binocular / military
eyepieces for RD, resulting in +ve AMD (pincussion). Residual
distortion is played off by deliberately introducing astigmatism,
pulling the Petval surface onto the sagittal surface.

An eyepiece designed for a specific OG can be corrected for distortion
more effectively by playing the field curvatures off against one
another, whilst at the same time correcting for hypochromatism
(eye-eyepiece-objective combination).

The way round the problem is aspherics, and it surprises me that given
all the patents recently taken out (since 1998) for moulded optical
aspheric shells, which have found there uses in telephoto zoom lenses,
that few have been used in uwa eyepieces. An aspheric eye lens shell
can also eliminate spherical aberration of the exit pupil.

Chris

I can only assume that Televue considers correction for rectilinear distortion is less of a priority than other design aspects they want to have in their eyepieces. Ocular design is always a tradeoff. Only Al could explain why he does what he does. I'm just happy he does. smile

DanL
Posted 09/13/2007 01:46PM #2
While we are on this subject, it brings up a question I have been meaning to pose to this group. When I am using a scope to just pan about the skies using I do find using a 31 Nag a bit dizzying after a while. So I would like recommendations from the group as to what you feel is a good wide field eyepiece (30mm +) with at lease a 70* afov and is well corrected for rectilinear distortion and minimal pincushion effect.

DanL