1.25" eyepiece adapter throwing off collimation?

Started by Ryan Koch, 10/22/2006 05:49AM
Posted 10/22/2006 05:49AM Opening Post
I was attempting to collimate my MN66 tonight when I ran into an unexpected issue. I aligned my secondary using my laser in 2" mode (it's a Howie Glatter 2" and 1.25" combined collimator) and all seemed well. However, out of curiosity I tried using the laser in 1.25" mode with my 1.25" eyepiece adapter, and to my surprise in this mode it shows the secondary collimation being off by quite a bit (laser in 1.25" mode hits part of the donut, while in 2" mode it's dead center). Thinking I might just of had a misaligned adapter I tried 2 other ones I had (an astro physics and a JMI), all had the same issue. So my question is, anyone else experience this? And any advice on which reading I should go off of? My instincts say to go with the 2" since that doesn't have any other elements involved to add extra slop, but then my chesire I use for primary collimation is 1.25". Also, I almost exclusively use 1.25" eyepieces...so wouldn't it make more sense just to align everything in that mode?

Thanks in advance for any advice :S
Posted 10/22/2006 08:04PM #1
Ryan
I have had collimation concerns stemming from the 2"-1.25" adapter. Since I use 1.25" EPs almost exclusively, my solution (perhaps flawed) is to position my adapter in the same position during collimation and EP insertion. The compression clamp in the adapter deflects the EP slightly, however I cannot detect the deflection in my cheshire. the laser collimator is highly sensitive to this deflection. Just now I collimated with the cheshire, then inserted the laser. When the laser is seated firmly and clamped down firmly the dot was centered in the donut. If not clamped firmly, the laser can be moved in the adapter negating any efforts to collimate. Thus, I must be diligent in seating the adapter insuring that is is pressed flush into position then clamped firmly. The same process is used when inserting an EP. Because of the uncertainty with the laser, my solution is to always collimate with the cheshire. I can adjust both the secondary and primary with it. Then confirm with a properly seated laser. A quality collimation tool is not available to me, so it has not been possible to check my method other than with my 2" Jim Fly Catseye which is just a peep hole with a reflective donut built in. My feeling is that the cheshire is a little more accurate.


I Yam What I Yam!