High quality 'planetary' reflectors?

Started by drachal, 08/06/2008 05:18AM
Posted 08/06/2008 05:18AM Opening Post
Is there any company making quality 'planetary' newtonians? I believe Starsplitter once made a 6"F9(?) Dob optimized for planet observing.

Darian R.
Posted 08/06/2008 11:04AM #1
Darian Rachal said:

Is there any company making quality 'planetary' newtonians? I believe Starsplitter once made a 6"F9(?) Dob optimized for planet observing.

It is my experience that the most important factor in getting the good planetary views is the aperture, one is almost always better off with a bigger, faster scope than a smaller slower scope when it comes to getting the good planetary views. My collection of Newtonians includes (or has included) some pretty decent 6 inch F/8's, 8 inch f/6's, 10 inch f/5 and a 12.5 inch F/4.06. Each of these has a focal length in the neighborhood of 50 inches.

Each step up the ladder, requires more attention to detail, collimation needs to be spot on, the bigger mirror time to cool down... A Paracorr will be needed at some point.

But the detail, sharpness and contrast improve with every step of the way.

So, my thinking is that there are plenty of high quality "planetary" reflectors available, in general though, they are not small and slow but rather big and fast... (and not so cheap)

Jon
Posted 08/06/2008 01:02PM | Edited 08/06/2008 01:31PM #2
Hi Darian,

Parallax Instruments makes several fine Newtonians in sizes from an 8" F/7.5 to a 16" F/6:

http://www.parallaxinstruments.com/newt.htm

And Bob Royce is making a small number of planetary optimized Dall-Kirkham scopes in 10" (One of which I own) and now a 12.5" both F/20:

http://www.rfroyce.com/

The Royce 10" F/20 is a planetary killer and the images superb. I prefer being able to remain seated while observing as it is more stable and relaxed enabling better attention to viewing. Bob's D-Ks allow that as well. I recently read that Discovery was brigibg out a planetary line with an 8" F/9 and a 10" F/7.5 if I recall.

In my mind a planetary reflector requires an 8" or larger mirror of excellent optical quality, longish focal length, small central obstruction, a spider that minimizes diffraction and an effective cooling system. It would not require a 2" focuser as, in my opinion, the best planetary eyepieces are 1.25" format and the smaller focuser would allow a smaller diagonal/less CO. Having said that, the Mak-Newt scopes, particularly the MN76 and larger are superb though the front corrector can be a problem w/r to dewing.
Posted 08/06/2008 05:20PM #3
Thanks to all who responded to my inquiry and for the links as well. You have provided a lot of useful information. smile

Darian R.
Posted 08/07/2008 01:29AM #4
Darian Rachal said:

Is there any company making quality 'planetary' newtonians? I believe Starsplitter once made a 6"F9(?) Dob optimized for planet observing.

Seems the days of long focus Newts are long gone. I owned my share of 8 to 14.5" Newts from f6.5 to f10, but none of them could compare with my Starmasters and Obsession on the planets.

As we all know the Starmaster and Obsession Dobs are well under F6,just have good seeing and dead on collimation and enjoy the view.

Chas
Posted 05/30/2009 09:59AM #5
Darian Rachal said:

Is there any company making quality 'planetary' newtonians?

Waiting to see what happens here... http://dodgenoptical.com/telescopes.php
Tim