Mysterious optical phenomenon

Started by auriga, 01/04/2009 10:56PM
Posted 01/04/2009 10:56PM Opening Post
Hi, all,
I am posting this here because the phenomenon occurs in a reflector in my case, and there appears to be the biggest density of optical gurus on this forum.

I noticed the phenomenon while looking at Rigel and Sirius through my 16 inch f/4.0 reflector in slightly hazy skies. Rigel and Sirius were both surrounded by zillions of little bright spikes, like diffraction spikes from a disgonal holder but very much smaller and almost infinitely numerous.
This is quite different from the intense round image I was used to on Vega with my 11" reflector.

The phenomenon is not discussed in Rutten and Van Rooj. I don't have Suiter, but I have never seen it illustrated in any article on star testing. It appears not to be discussed in any book I can find and in no web article. It took me two hours with Google to even find out its name: "radial spiking."

I can find only two referecnes to it, one in a Sky $ Telescope article in Sept. 2005 issue, p. 35, the only issue I don't have from that year. The other is a set of posts by Ed Zarenski on CN in the binocular forum. This defect is apparently characteristic of some binoculars.
There is no real explanation given, but Ed, whom I respect, says it is caused by a lens (or occasionally by reflections from a binocular prism.)

An optical friend of mine suggests it may be caused by my eyepiece.

The eyepieces in question are a 13E and an 8E, both used wiht a Paracorr. The telescope mirror tests as essentially perfect, and the scope was colllimated using a Howie Glatter 2 inch laser colllimator plus a Blug. The focuser is a Feathertouch.

It's hard for me to see how any of the above could have caused the problem. The magnifications with the 13E and the 8E were 140x and 233x respectively.

Because of the image defect, Rigel B was surprisingly difficult for me at 140x although I saw it after my spouse pointed it out. At 233x it was much easier. But not as easy as it has previously been in my 6"f/5 reflector.

Problems were less on dimmer stars. The E star in the Trapezium was easy.

As the mad scientist that I am, I came up with all kinds of ingenious theories that the defect was in my eyes, until my wife pointed out that she saw the radial spikes too and remarked on how obtrusive they were.

I am sure this phenomenon is due to some simple thing I am overlooking, and I welcome any suggestions. Thanks in advance,

Bill Meyers
Posted 01/04/2009 11:05PM | Edited 01/04/2009 11:14PM #1
Atmospheric seeing.
Or more specifically, atmospheric turbulence effecting the "seeing".
Posted 01/05/2009 03:53AM #2
If they are radial, they are not caused by seeing or tube currents. Try masking off about 1/4 to 1/3 of an inch of the periphery of the mirror. If the spikes are reduced, then you have the answer - turned edge. If you see it when you slightly defocus on one side but not the other, then it is almost certainly turned edge.

Rolando