Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Should there be a profit?

Started by fblue, 04/11/2007 06:06PM
Posted 04/11/2007 06:06PM Opening Post
The latest thread seemed to imply that there was just too much profit being made on higher end optics and scopes, especially DOBs.
Now I have to ask the question. If you were going to make a DOB and spend a large amount of hours making it, a bit of money advertising it and then money spent supporting it, what would you consider to be a fair profit?
If it cost you $3,000 to make a scope and took 40 hours to build it, would $4,000 be too much? That would be $25 an hour minus the cost of running the business, including utilities and rent as well as advertising and phone bills. 40 hours is what most consider a work week, so $1,000 a week less expenses is too much? Don't foget the employees that like to eat! smile
How about a mirror maker? If he sells a 10" mirror for $1000 and it cost $100-180 for the blank, then has to re anneal, it which takes an electric kiln and about 2 weeks time, the machine work and hand work on the polishing and figuring. !2 hours to 24 hours on the machine and then however long it takes to finish the figure by hand. Now add to that $100 for coating with standard coatings and then shipping both to the coater and to the customer.
The machines don't come free, the electricity is not cheap and there are all the other bills or employees to pay. Plus the optician deserves to feed his family and have a nice place to live just like any other person, right?
I have talked with many people that built their own telescope and the cost was still not cheap if a good set of mirrors, a nice focuser and the other hardware are used. Then there is quite a lot of labor, hours and hours of it. Consider how much you would have made if you were working instead of building!
All in all, is it really that expensive for a great scope of set of optics? :S

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 04/11/2007 06:39PM #1
Floyd Blue said:


If it cost you $3,000 to make a scope and took 40 hours to build it, would $4,000 be too much? That would be $25 an hour minus the cost of running the business, including utilities and rent as well as advertising and phone bills. 40 hours is what most consider a work week, so $1,000 a week less expenses is too much? Don't foget the employees that like to eat! smile
How are we coming up with the original $3000 cost to produce this scope?
Posted 04/11/2007 07:18PM #2
Floyd Blue said:
... would $4,000 be too much? That would be $25 an hour minus the cost of running the business, including utilities and rent as well as advertising and phone bills ...

Obsession's 12.5 with Feathertouch is $3,370, and Starmaster's 11 with Feathertouch is about $3,400. And I don't think anyone would work that hard and take those business risks for $25/hr.

So, your cost estimate is probably too high.

And, $4,000 is probably too much to charge.

I think there are at least three segments to the 'real telescope' buying public. On one end, price is by far the dominant factor. The middle might be characterized by 'most value for the money'. The high end is highest quality and usually highest prices.
I would guess that the smallest group is the high end buyer, so it is a segment that is not easily penetrated. Established, proven brands attract the high end buyer. If someone wanted to compete in this area they would have to get a big name mirror, Feathertouch focuser, etc. - and charge less than the established brands. Not easy.
Posted 04/11/2007 10:27PM #3
>>>Now I have to ask the question. If you were going to make a DOB and spend a large amount of hours making it, a bit of money advertising it and then money spent supporting it, what would you consider to be a fair profit?
----

Floyd:

In reality: Any amount anyone will pay you is probably not enough to call it a "profit." Not matter how much each scope costs to make, how much each scope sells for, part of the motivation has to be love.

Jon

Posted 04/11/2007 11:31PM #4
Of course there should be a profit. The marketplace will
decide if it is too much; the scope builders will decide
if it is too little. There is probably some segment of
the market where no price is too high, so long as there
is extra value for extra money. There is also
a market segment that wants the lowest price possible, and
may be flexible about the quality of the product, or willing
to re-work an item of marginal quality.

We have seen a number of scope makers and
dealers getting out in the last 6 months. Clearly for
these folks there was not enough profit. That is the
real test. Love of the hobby is nice, but only goes
so far. How low do you want the prices? How
many more do you want to see get out? Are we happy
if Guan-Sheng is the last and only scope maker?
Posted 04/12/2007 04:23AM #5
I know Floyd is just offering a forum to discuss this, but this is really a dumb topic on so many levels, spurred on by a few ill-conceived posts from an earlier thread.

If a scope costs more than you are willing to spend, rationalize or justify it any way you want, and then go build/buy something else.

If you can afford the scope, you want the scope, and you are satisfied that the claims of quality are valid, then buy the scope.

If you are making scopes and/or mirrors for others, you can either make a profit (of your definition) or decide to make them in your spare time while you work at another job (or live on your retirement or investments). The market will let you know how you're doing.

Assertions that anyone is making a lot of money producing commercial dobs are not worth discussing.