Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

TV102 Competition

Started by wpaolini, 05/05/2008 11:14PM
Posted 05/05/2008 11:14PM Opening Post
About ready to get a TV102 refractor. Before I do, wanted to get some feedback from folks who have or viewed thru one of these and ask what refractor in the same aperture class they think is a tad better optically and also one they think is just a tad worse optically. And if you can, how the one that is better excels over the TV102 and how the one that is worse falls short.

Please only compare other refractors of appox 4" in you list.

Thx!
Posted 05/06/2008 12:52AM #1
btw - I forgot to mention, am using this for lunar/planetary observing.
Posted 05/06/2008 08:00PM #2
William Paolini said:
And if you can, how the one that is better excels over the TV102 and how the one that is worse falls short.

Optically a little better: Celestron or Vixen 102 Flourite. Less false color.
Lens figure similar or better. Some claim TV 102 has brighter image or
better contrast, but I have not noticed this myself.

Optically much beter: TMB 100 F8. Much less false color. Very high strehl
ratio lenses available.

Optically a little worse: AP 105 Traveler. More false color, but of course
its much faster at F/6. More for imaging and portability.

Confusing: Takahashi FS 102. Three units tested better than
TV 102, two worse. Design has less false color, but some
units had strange aberrations.
Posted 05/07/2008 03:16AM #3
TV102 - great little scope. Mechanically, I'd suggest the feathertouch focuser upgrade.......optically, it is a great litle 4" scope that seems to take power well for lunar and planetary observing. I routinely am able to use a 3.5mm Nagler (251x) for the moon and Saturn, and have pushed to the 2.5mm Nagler (352x) on rare occasions.

I'm very pleased with mine!

Mike

http://www.DarkSights.com
Posted 05/07/2008 03:48PM #4
The characteristics of the TV 102 are (in no particular order):

1)Good APO performance (colour/figure/etc.).

2)Longish focal ratio for lessened demands on eyepieces and ability to use longer FL eyepieces for same magnification

3)High quality optics and excellent robust mechanics

4)quick cooldown

5) Decent price (~$2,000 for OTA or ~2,400 for OTA + accessories).

It would seem to me that the natural competitor to the TV-102 is the Takahashi TSA-102.

They both have the longer focal ratio but the TSA has the advantage in better colour correction at the disadvantage of a longer cooldown. However, cooldown in any 4" APO is not terribly long.

The TV is slightly lighter and cheaper, but the TSA has a larger focuser perhaps more comparible to the TV-102is rather than the base TV-102.

If I were choosing between these two scopes, I would most likely pick the TSA-102 over the TV-102 (is or not).

Philip




William Paolini said:
About ready to get a TV102 refractor.