Image of the day

Captured by
Arthur Hogan

Wizard Nebula

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

12.5 mirror grinding dilema

Started by Grumpy_one, 05/03/2004 09:55PM
Posted 05/03/2004 09:55PM Opening Post
Once again I have a question about my mirror. I was able to push it out to the edge. Thanks to those who answered, it helped. But now that I'm out to the edge, I'ts still only a f/6, I was hoping for a f/7, f/8, f/7.5 would be ideal. So here's my question: is it worth the extra grinding time for the f/7.5? or is the f/6 good enough? what would I gain having a f/7.5 vs f/6? (smaller secondary?), f/6 vs f/7.5 more portability?). Thanks, DaveT

One more note: I am up to grit 180, I found out that the f ratio doesnt change much at this grit. If the longer focal length is worth it, I dont mind going back a couple of grits. I also have a couple of pits I missed when I changed grits that I missed during inspection. Wouldn't mind getting rid of those also, probably being too picky at this point concerning the pits. Thanks again
Posted 05/03/2004 11:09PM #1
I would think an f/6 would be quite nice. Little coma and more FOV, plus a shorter scope, maybe 5.5' at the EP. A 12.5" f/8 is 7.7' to the EP not counting the extra for the rocker box. So it could get close to 8' high. Now that is a ladder scope for sure.
F/6 is actually nice as it is pretty forgiving on collimation.
Floyd

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 05/04/2004 01:07AM #2
David,
How high do you want your ladder or how portable do you want it? Mine had to fit in my car so I made it F/5. Otherwise everthing else gets better with longer focal length.
Ed
Posted 05/04/2004 01:16AM #3
David,

Portability is certainly a concern. Longer tubes are tougher to manage, but you're the one who has to decide what is manageable. Aside from handling the size and bulk, there is storage to think about, transportation if you need to travel with the scope, and, especially, the greater difficulty of providing a solid mount for a longer tube (greater toque and greater wind loading). The picture improves if you are putting it in an observatory.

Personally, I'd aim for the best darn f/6 mirror I could manage. If you get it right, and keep the secondary down to 25 percent or less, you should be in good shape.

Clear skies, Alan
Posted 05/04/2004 06:14PM #4
Dave, something else to consider above all the other good advice given is difficulty in figuring. The faster the more difficult. I shouldn't really say more difficult, but the tolerances involved in figuring a fast mirror are tighter than for a slower mirror of the same diameter. Probably not a huge difference between f/6 and f/7.5, but not trivial either.

Good luck,
Doug
Posted 05/05/2004 03:40AM #5
David
Nothing wrong with an f6. While its true that tolerences are a little tighter at f6 than f8, you gain in ease of mounting and portability. You are simply doing a trade-off. I don't quite understand the part about keeping up. Are you in a mirror making class? I don't recommend leaving pits. If you see them clearly, I'd consider going back a few grits and grinding them out. No need to return to step 1.

Good luck with your mirror
Russ