Image of the day

Captured by
Ruben Tommasi

Andromeda Galaxy (M31)

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

26 inch F8 or higher

Started by yahganlang, 08/21/2008 01:02AM
Posted 08/21/2008 01:02AM Opening Post
Since most large apertures come in fast speeds, I'm curious about what one might see in a slow speed with large aperture- I chose 26" because this is the size flat I have.

Supposing one were to core it and make a classical Cass, or Nasmyth, or if it had a siderostat etc., I'd like to know, assuming a good figure, alignments, ep's etc., what the performance limits would be.

How would something that big do on planets, or globulars, galaxies? Would the larger focal ratio hurt on the latter, given the larger primary in the first place?

Thanks.
Jess Tauber
Posted 08/21/2008 01:16AM #1
No matter what the f/ratio, the telescope still has the same light grasp and the same potential resolution. What changes is the image scale, and a slower scope may not allow as wide a field as a faster one, depending on the eyepieces available.

Of course, the central obstruction you have will play a small role here, but with 26" aperture to start with I wouldn't be too concerned if it is kept reasonable. The trick would be to have it where the skies are steady enough to really strut its stuff. Dark would be nice too.

Clear skies, Alan
Posted 08/21/2008 05:56AM #2
Hi Jess,

Is this actually a decent flat mirror ? Have you tried to test it against any other known flats ?

It might be more useful as a flat, rather than a blank to be ground into a telescope.

David Simons
Posted 08/21/2008 10:43AM #3

Supposing one were to core it and make a classical Cass, or Nasmyth, or if it had a siderostat etc., I'd like to know, assuming a good figure, alignments, ep's etc., what the performance limits would be.

How would something that big do on planets, or globulars, galaxies? Would the larger focal ratio hurt on the latter, given the larger primary in the first place?


As others have said, the limits on performance are still the aperture, the thermal equilibrium of the telescope and the seeing. In comparison to a large, fast Newtonian with correcting optics (Paracorr etc), I suspect the views would not be too much different except for the somewhat limited field of view with existing eyepieces. I calculate a 41mm Pan-Optic would provide a half a degree TFoV at about 130x with a 5mm exit pupil. That's quite reasonable as a maximum field of view in a scope this big.

One issue that is important to consider is the structure of the telescope itself. One of the reasons Newtonians are popular as ATM scopes is their lax collimation requirements. With only one curved mirror, the Newtonian is significantly more tolerant when it comes to alignment issues. Thus the structure can be comparatively flexible, one can get by successfully with a DOB design. The tendency is to consider that collimation of the Newtonian as a big issue but actually the reverse is true... No other design could get away with the same sort of lightweight, flexible structures...

That's my two cents and I'm stickin with it even if I am wrong... smile

Jon