Image of the day

Captured by
Douglas Rollain

SH2-157_Seestar_S30_Pro

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Craziest question of the year, by far!

Started by Joel Elliott, 10/25/2003 04:32PM
Posted 10/25/2003 04:32PM Opening Post
Fellas,

Alrighty, here's a good 'un. I was browsing the D&G website earlier this year and saw something that keeps me wondering. They've gotten up a line of long-focus refractor doublets, no news there, but now they can render them in rather long focal ratios. Even f/30!
So - let's imagine you had a way to mount up two 10 inch f/30 tubes in a giant binocular system. The spread would be about 550 inches or so, under the way I'd do it in my obviously deranged mind. This crazy idea has been dogging me all year. Math Guys: Is this wide enough to render a 3D image of the moon, parallax-wise?
I know that binoviewer owners report 3D like images all the time, but clearly this is an illusion. Good for them, and I mean that nicely. But seriously though, how wide a spread would it take to get a parallax rendered, genuine 3D image of something about 300,000 miles away?
Does anyone know the math involved in such a computation?

Nuts in NC,
J. Elliott
Posted 10/25/2003 06:10PM #1
A 550" wide binocular? Like a military range-finder? Wow, that's original.
Posted 11/25/2003 04:01AM #2
Why would such a binocular have to be mechanical? Couldn't you have a buddy in England stream images onto the web at the same time as you (I assume you're in the states), and you could both view the images through your "virtual binocular" in realtime. You'd have a small time window where it's dark in both places, and the weather would have to decent in both places of course. It wouldn't do to have sun in one eye and fog in the other!

I don't know how to do the math, but if a separation of a few thousand miles is sufficient to trick our eyes and brains into seeing a 3-D image, it seems like this should be both cheap and doable. The sort of thing the eccentric Brits would go in for.

I dub it: Binoc-zilla!

Garry Buck
Tucson, Arizona