Mike,
Sorry to jump in late also.
I have enhanced coatings on both mirrors of my 13.1" dob. I don't see any scatter attributable to the coatings, but figure-wise the primary is average, so it's hard to tell. I had the primary coated by Precision Applied Products, about ten years ago, and the secondary is a Lumicon 2.6". Both are coated with enhanced aluminum.
I was seeing stars down to 16th magnitude at the Black Forest Star Party under mag 6.4 skies a few weeks ago. Theoretically, I should only be able to go down to around 15.5.
Many folks who look through my scope comment on how contrasty the images are, and I can't disagree.
If enhanced caotings are problematic, then you can't prove it by me.
Anecdotal, yes, but hope this helps anyway.
Regards,
Doug
Sorry to jump in late also.
I have enhanced coatings on both mirrors of my 13.1" dob. I don't see any scatter attributable to the coatings, but figure-wise the primary is average, so it's hard to tell. I had the primary coated by Precision Applied Products, about ten years ago, and the secondary is a Lumicon 2.6". Both are coated with enhanced aluminum.
I was seeing stars down to 16th magnitude at the Black Forest Star Party under mag 6.4 skies a few weeks ago. Theoretically, I should only be able to go down to around 15.5.
Many folks who look through my scope comment on how contrasty the images are, and I can't disagree.
If enhanced caotings are problematic, then you can't prove it by me.
Anecdotal, yes, but hope this helps anyway.
Regards,
Doug