Image of the day

Captured by
Bruce Karbal

VDB 142 Elephant Trunk HOO

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Protostar curved vane spider for planets?

Started by ronbee, 05/07/2004 06:42PM
Posted 05/07/2004 06:42PM Opening Post
I'm thinking about replacing my 8" Discovery PDHQ (with 4 vane spiders) with a customed 8" f/6 Dobs with Royce mirror and Protostar support. This is will be my planetary Dob (with some infrequent DSOs viewing). Protostar has 3-vane, 4-vane and curved support. Here's a simulated view they showed with the 3 different supports. http://www.fpi-protostar.com/images1/spikes.jpg

I've read the various threads on this forum and didn't seem to be any consensus on which is better. Do you guys think the curved vane support will be best for elking that minute, low contrast details of the planets/Moon? It sure looks like it gives a very fine image (from the link), very "refractor-like" it seems. Of the 4-vane, 3-vane, and curved vane, which would you prefer/recommend for my intended use and why?

Thanks,
Ron B[ee]


Posted 05/07/2004 07:39PM #1
Ron, my choice would be the one with the least amount of TOTAL diffraction. I think the Protostar curved vane (single semicircle) accomplishes that vs. even their three vane, plus no spikes to boot.

I'm currently saving my pennies to get one for my 8" f/8.

My $.02
Doug Scobel