Questioning the Mirror Box Cutaway

Started by toml, 01/23/2005 06:39PM
Posted 01/23/2005 06:39PM | Edited 01/23/2005 06:49PM Opening Post
Speaking of questioning everything
( http://www.astromart.com/forums/viewpost.asp?forum_post_id=294641 )

I am about to cutaway my bottom corner, a la K-B page 192 (diagram p.191). If you don't have your bible in front of you, I'll paraphrase: they say to scribe an arc centered on the center top edge of the side panel (ie. what is assumed to be the center point of the pivot) starting at the bottom edge where the tailgate ends and up until it hits the edge that would join the front of the box.

I'm sure you follow me. Half the boxes I see out there are just 45° cuts, but KB say a curve looks nicer (and I'm inclined to agree). But looks aside, the arc I scribed struck me as quite shallow. Though geomtrically correct (it would minimally clear the rocker box when rotated about that pivot point). I realized that a LOT more material (and hence weight when using BB Ply) would be removed by that plain 45° cut.

For that matter, my questioning continued: why not 60°. Or more?

I am not bottom heavy or anything, it's just a thought experiment that happened when I wondered about how little this arc was and should I just do a 45 instead?

Should I? Pros? Cons? Set me straight*!!!

*or curved smile

TomL

PS maybe the choice would come down to not just weight removal (if that's at issue) but also how you would cover that hole afterwards. 1/8" thin ply for a 45, but what about a curved cut? Veneer? Open?
Posted 01/23/2005 06:49PM #1
Both of my home builts had 90° square boxes and had no problems at all. Take a look at the 15".


Attached Image:

fblue's attachment for post 87379

[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue grin
Amateur Imager
Posted 01/23/2005 07:02PM #2
I used a 45 degree cut on mine, purely to get clearance for the mirror box. I really can't see that a curve would be functionally different. If it pleases you, why not?
Posted 01/23/2005 08:59PM #3
Tom,

The cut lives inside the rocker box or worst cast pointing at the ground. Cut whatever is easiest and gives you the proper clearance. The difference in look and probably weight will be minimal. Make sure you do not cutaway where your tailgate should be. It looks better totally covered.

Ed
Posted 01/24/2005 02:07PM #4
>>"For that matter, my questioning continued: why not 60°. Or more?"

As has been pointed out, the purpose of the cut is so that you can shorten the whole scope and lower the eyepiece. If you did not cut that corner, you would have to make the rocker box slightly higher to accommodate the mirror box swinging through.

You can cut it to any pattern you like. But you cut off as much corner as you can cut at 45 degrees.

If you want to cut more, you aren't shortening the scope, but you are eventually losing strength in the box. (Your 45 degree cut loses some, but it is worth the loss.)

Therefore, 45 degrees does what you want in the way of shortening the scope, and any more weakens the box unnecessarily.

Alex