My primary will be a 12.5 f/6.4 Swayze mirror. Pro's con's for quartz vs Pyrex. Besides the money. Thanks
Secondary mirror
Started by Grumpy_one, 06/12/2004 10:35PM
Posted 06/12/2004 10:35PM
Opening Post
Posted 06/13/2004 12:24AM
| Edited 06/13/2004 12:29AM
#2
I guess you must decide whether the money is best spent there at the elliptical flat, or elsewhere. I am not sure that the human eye is going to see a lot of difference on a normal night of viewing. Mostly the scope will be atmosphere limited with either mirror. On those very special nights then you might just see a difference by seeing a star or detail that the other mirror did not show as well.
The cost difference is great but less than the cost of one good eyepiece, so I guess you could say that it is a good investment.
I am going to be buying a new diag mirror soon myself. I doubt that I will spend the extra 100% on the fused quartz. I will buy a good quality Pyrex with good coatings and fine flat surface. It will probably be a 1/12 wave maybe a 1/14 wave, but likely not a 1/20 or 1/30 wave due to the cost.
Each must make these decisions on their own though. Many might disagree with my choice.
Floyd
The cost difference is great but less than the cost of one good eyepiece, so I guess you could say that it is a good investment.
I am going to be buying a new diag mirror soon myself. I doubt that I will spend the extra 100% on the fused quartz. I will buy a good quality Pyrex with good coatings and fine flat surface. It will probably be a 1/12 wave maybe a 1/14 wave, but likely not a 1/20 or 1/30 wave due to the cost.
Each must make these decisions on their own though. Many might disagree with my choice.
Floyd
[SIZE="Large"][/SIZE][COLOR="Blue"][/COLOR] Floyd Blue
Amateur Imager
Posted 06/13/2004 01:04AM
#3
There are two reasons for choosing a fused quartz diagonal. The first reason is quartz's extremely low coeficient of linear expansion. There is almost an order of magnitude difference between fused quartz and pyrex (0.5x10E-6/degC vs 3.3x10E-6/degC). The low coef. of linear expansion for quartz essentially eliminates temperature effects from fused quartz diagonals. The second reason is made clear from Sherrod's post. Quartz is harder than pyrex and takes a better polish.
The best choice of diagonal material is quartz (Neglecting the money).
Russ Schnitzer
The best choice of diagonal material is quartz (Neglecting the money).
Russ Schnitzer
Funding Member