Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Secondary size for 10" reflector?

Started by Jozeph, 10/07/2003 08:02PM
Posted 10/07/2003 08:02PM Opening Post
I hope to build a 10" reflector soon, and will use an f/5 mirror and a 2" low-profile focuser. I've run the .nwt program to determine secondary size and it seems to be a trade-off between the amount of illuminated area and the size of the obstruction. For instance:

1.83" secondary
18% obstruction
0.11" 100% illuminated area
1.035" 75% illuminated area

2.14" secondary
21% obstruction
0.49" 100% illuminated area
1.38% 75% illuminated area

This scope will be primarily for deepsky visual use btw. I am hoping that I can get a bit of help here in determining which secondary size might be most appropriate for this project, and some explanation of why.

Last but not least, another option might be to go with an f/5.6 mirror:

1.83" secondary
18% obstruction
0.33" 100% illuminated area
1.13" 75% illuminated area

I would be losing a bit of wide field, but perhaps the trade-off of obstruction vs. illuminated area is better? (also less coma)

I've done some research on this, but would REALLY appreciate opinions others in this forum might be able to contribute re: obstruction size vs. illumination area.

Thanks!
Joe
Posted 10/07/2003 09:19PM #1
Well, a very important differentiating factor is the distance from the secondary to the focal plane. The 10" f/5 Teleport performs just fine with the 1.83" secondary, but it uses a low-profile focuser to keep the distance form secondary to focal plane short. If you want a conventional focuser, the distance will be greater, so you will tend to want the next larger secondary size, particularly for DSO observing. If you haven't experimented with the SEC program (available for download from the S&T site), I recommend that you do.
--
Mike
Posted 10/07/2003 09:22PM #2
Joe, the 1.83" secondary with the f/5 is IMHO a little too small. At low and even medium power and the small .11" FIF, only a small portion of the field will be using all 10" of the primary. Go with the 2.14". Contrast wise I doubt that you'll see a difference between a 18% and 21% CO. CO doesn't become much of an issue until you're up around 30%, so it doesn't make a lot of sense to go to f/5.6 just to get an extra 3%. It would help with coma, collimation, etc., though.

Hope this helps,
Doug Scobel
Posted 10/08/2003 11:56AM #3
Thanks for the input and suggestions folks, much obliged!