Which better- holing a flat, or making a flat from

Started by yahganlang, 08/15/2008 12:40AM
Posted 08/15/2008 12:40AM Opening Post
Let's suppose for the sake of argument that I want to have a mirrored flat with a hole through its center wide enough to pass a returning light cone that was originally deflected off the 45 degree flat to a primary (isn't there something like this at Stellafane??).

Anyway, which is better- to try to core a hole through an existing flat (prior to mirroring), or coring the blank first before making it into a flat? Will the former method destroy the flat figure?

One more thing- I want the hole to be at a 45 degree angle through the flat, so that the light cone goes right through with no unusable area on the flat.

Jess Tauber
Posted 08/15/2008 01:39AM | Edited 08/15/2008 01:46AM #1
Hi Jess,

The fellow who made my flat, bored the hole first, and the "plug" was held in place with wax I think during grinding and figuring. I didn't bother with having the hole bored at an angle, as the actual angle is fairly slight, although for a second mirror, I would try to have a slightly oversize flat, and the bore angle factored in.

Walter Scott Houston made a number of observations with the 12" Stellafane "Porter Turret" scope you reference that were written up in his observing columns.

I have some pictures of a scope somewhat similar to what you describe on my web page:

http://www.planetatm.com/

Scroll down a bit to get to it. I decided not to use a 45 degree angle, as the requirements on a 45 degree flat get very severe. One of the advantages to this design is how easy it is to get near "perfect" collimation, since you are looking essentially straight into the parabolic mirror. The images are not very Newtonian-like as there is no spider diffraction and the central obstruction can be made very small.

David Simons