Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Best choice for a deep sky observing?

Started by Midnight Sun, 01/28/2010 04:26PM
Posted 01/28/2010 04:26PM Opening Post
I have tried several Neb filters and found them too dark.. I end up removing them so I can actually see the objects. There is no light pollution where I live so that is not an issue.. I have a 11" SCT. Using a Nag 31T5 and a 22mm T4 Nag. thought the 31 was using too much light... thanks for any suggestions.. JM

Posted 01/28/2010 04:46PM #1
John Meiners said:

I have tried several Neb filters and found them too dark.. I end up removing them so I can actually see the objects. There is no light pollution where I live so that is not an issue.. I have a 11" SCT. Using a Nag 31T5 and a 22mm T4 Nag. thought the 31 was using too much light... thanks for any suggestions.. JM

The effectiveness of filters depends on the object. It also depends on your goals as an observer.

This is the way I look at it:

There are relatively few targets that respond to filtering, essentially filters are effective with various nebulae and generally the most effective nebula filter is the O-III though some are better suited to the H-beta filters.

But there is no free lunch, filters work by narrowing the passband or passbands, they restrict unwanted light and allow a narrow band of the spectrum to pass. Clearly this results in a darker image by design.

When viewing objects like the Swan Nebula or the Lagoon that have associated star clusters, there is a compromise. Since the stars are full spectrum, they will be noticeably reduced in brightness.

THere is also the issue of exit pupil... At F/10, your SCT will provide a 3.1mm exit pupil with the 31mm Nagler, this is not a bright image to begin with so the loss of brightness will be more apparent. A 3.1mm exit pupil is getting near the limit for many targets, larger is better in many situations.

With a faster scope, I do most of my deep sky observing with Newtonians in the F/5 and under range, the view is much brighter so filters can be more effective. For a given eyepiece, the view in an F/5 is 4 times brighter than in an F/10, so that is definitely significant.

The image brightness is one reason why it might be desirable for you to add one of the 55mm Plossls to your collection. The True Field of View will be no greater than the 31mm Nagler but the image will be about 3 times brighter and with an effective filter like an O-III the image will be still quite bright.

That's the way it works for me...

Jon Isaacs
Posted 01/30/2010 12:47AM #2
John Meiners said:

I have tried several Neb filters and found them too dark.. I end up removing them so I can actually see the objects. There is no light pollution where I live so that is not an issue.. I have a 11" SCT. Using a Nag 31T5 and a 22mm T4 Nag. thought the 31 was using too much light... thanks for any suggestions.. JM

Jon Isaacs certainly offers good advice. I prefer the slightly broader band UHC to the O III, but would add that a plenty of people prefer the O III. I am using an 8" f 5.7.

I also find that I am somewhat conflicted about whether or not I can actually see more with or without the filter.

As Jon says, it's a compromise.