Image of the day

Captured by
Lawrence Parchman

Eastern Veil Nebula (NGC 6992) - Wide View

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

How Bad is this $50 Meade Diagonal?

Started by ps, 12/15/2007 02:01AM
Posted 12/15/2007 02:01AM Opening Post
Last year I purchased a used 10” LX200 Classic that came with a 2” Meade diagonal (see attached photo). It’s made almost entirely out of plastic. Even the 1.25” adapter is plastic. Would upgrading to a higher quality diagonal (enhanced or dielectric) make a significant difference? My eps include a 4.8mm Nagler, 20mm Televue plossl, 32mm Optiluxe, 28mm & 18mm Meade SWA and various house brand plossls ranging from 5mm to 25mm. Any comments and / or suggestions will be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance. Paul smile

Attached Image:

ps's attachment for post 40057

Meade 10" LX200
C9.25 ASGT
Orion 10" XTi
Orion 80mm ST
Posted 12/15/2007 02:57AM #1
Paul,

I have one of those diagonals. It is not entirely plastic, the mirror is glass.

I use mine on a light weight 80mm finder for low power use only. For that it is OK.

Optically it may even been OK as very little of the mirror surface contibutes to any one point in the final image. However, you can do much better and will probably notice a difference at anything other than your lowest power. I would not want to hang too much weight on this plastic body. There are lots of well made lower cost dielectric diagonals on the market now that weren't available two years ago.

Treat yourself to an upgrade. It's Christmas time.

clear skies,
dan
Posted 12/15/2007 05:41AM #2
Paul:

Normally I don't think a diagonal makes a huge difference but in this case I think there is likely something to be gained. That diagonal looks like one from one of the DS series scopes and my experience with those suggests there are better optics around...

Jon
Posted 12/16/2007 04:00AM #3
Seriously, considering the quality of the rest of your equipment, just get a 99% dielectric and be done with it. Make sure you get compression rings instead of set screws also.
Posted 12/17/2007 06:14PM #4
Thanks for all the great suggestions. I’m hoping to find a new 2” diagonal under the Christmas tree this year. Here’s wishing all of you a wonderful Christmas and a Happy New Years. Paul smile

Meade 10" LX200
C9.25 ASGT
Orion 10" XTi
Orion 80mm ST