Image of the day

Captured by
Michael Scherman

M17 Swan-Omega Celestron C6 Hyperstar2

My Account

New to Astromart?

Register an account...

Need Help?

Can you see these galactic details?

Started by Inge_S, 11/15/2006 07:33AM
Posted 11/15/2006 07:33AM Opening Post
I want to make a list where galactic features are ranked by difficulty. For this I need the input of all of you. At the end of this post is a list of different features, and I want you to make a statement about which of them you have actually seen through your telescope. If you have several telescopes it is interesting to know the results for each of them individually.

Use the following "scale" to express what you see:

A: The feature is seen with direct vision.
B: The feature is seen with averted vision.
C: The feature is suspected with averted vision.
D: The feature can not be seen
E: Have never tried to observe the object (or can't remember).

Additional comments can be given.
Please, give information about telescope aperture and observing conditions (dark, suburban, lousy...).

THIS IS NOT A COMPETITION! Please be honest and realistic! In this case "D" and "E" scores are just as interesting as "A" and "B". Some of the features are moderately easy to see while others are more difficult.

Here's the list (in random order):

1: Dust bands in M82
2: Spiral arms of M61
3: Equatorial dust band of NGC891
4: Spiral arms of M33
5: The obscuring cloud of M64 ("Black eye")
6: Spiral arms of M51
7: Emission nebula, NGC604 in M33
8: Dust bands in NGC3556
9: Spiral arms of M99
10: One dust band in the Andromeda galaxy
11: Spiral arms of M101
12: Equatorial dust band of NGC3628 (The one near M65/66)
13: Two dust bands in the Andromeda galaxy
14: Emission nebulae in the spiral arms of M101
15: Spiral arms of M100
16: Equatorial dust band of NGC4565 (Coma Berenices)
17: "Bend" of galaxy NGC4656 (Canes Venatici)
18: Spiral arms of NGC2403
19: Spiral arms of NGC2903
20: Bridge between M51 and companion galaxy

All contributions are welcome.

Inge S
Posted 11/15/2006 10:46AM #1
Between my eye and my sky (and my Coulter) I haven't seen ANY of these details. Drat!

Jess Tauber
Posted 11/15/2006 12:33PM | Edited 11/16/2006 07:51AM #2
This is just off the top of my head, using quite a mix of telescopes up to 32 inches in aperture:

1: Dust bands in M82 A
2: Spiral arms of M61 I don't recall
3: Equatorial dust band of NGC891 A
4: Spiral arms of M33 A
5: The obscuring cloud of M64 ("Black eye") A
6: Spiral arms of M51 A
7: Emission nebula, NGC604 in M33 A
8: Dust bands in NGC3556 I don't recall
9: Spiral arms of M99 A
10: One dust band in the Andromeda galaxy A
11: Spiral arms of M101 A
12: Equatorial dust band of NGC3628 (The one near M65/66) A
13: Two dust bands in the Andromeda galaxy A
14: Emission nebulae in the spiral arms of M101 A
15: Spiral arms of M100 I don't recall
16: Equatorial dust band of NGC4565 (Coma Berenices) A
17: "Bend" of galaxy NGC4656 (Canes Venatici) I don't recall
18: Spiral arms of NGC2403 A
19: Spiral arms of NGC2903 A
20: Bridge between M51 and companion galaxy A

Dave Mitsky

Chance favors the prepared mind.

De gustibus non est disputandum.
Posted 11/15/2006 01:27PM #3
Hello,
Here is my list ...great question!!
1.a 11.d
2.d 12.d
3.a 13.a
4.d 14.d
5.b 15.d
6.c 16.d
7.e 17.e
8.e 18.e
9.d 19.e
10.a 20.b
Posted 11/15/2006 06:43PM | Edited 11/17/2006 08:35PM #4
With a relatively new 16" in dark skies, the following are direct vision:
1. dust bands in M82
(edited since first version, I confused M81 and M82, dang needed some caffeine)
3. dust band 891
4. spiral arms M33
5. black eye M64
6. spiral arms M51
7. 604 in M33 along with several other nebula regions
11. spiral arms M101 (this varies from night to night, some nights the arms are more averted vision, I use this as an indicator of sky quality)
13. two dust bands M31, again a sky quality indicator

Only suspected:
20. bridge of M51

The others haven't viewed recently or noticed the feature or I have forgotten, I am terrible at notes too much work.

thanks for the questions.

Mike







Posted 11/16/2006 05:41AM #5
Hello:
I have observed many of these with a 12.5" cassegrain at a dark site.

1: Dust bands in M82 A
2: Spiral arms of M61 E
3: Equatorial dust band of NGC891 A
4: Spiral arms of M33 A
5: The obscuring cloud of M64 ("Black eye") A
6: Spiral arms of M51 A
7: Emission nebula, NGC604 in M33 A
8: Dust bands in NGC3556 E
9: Spiral arms of M99 E
10: One dust band in the Andromeda galaxy A
11: Spiral arms of M101 A
12: Equatorial dust band of NGC3628 A
13: Two dust bands in the Andromeda galaxy A
14: Emission nebulae in the spiral arms of M101 B
15: Spiral arms of M100 E
16: Equatorial dust band of NGC4565 (Coma Berenices) A
17: "Bend" of galaxy NGC4656 (Canes Venatici) E
18: Spiral arms of NGC2403 E
19: Spiral arms of NGC2903 E
20: Bridge between M51 and companion galaxy B

Cheers
Mike Connelley
Posted 11/16/2006 03:23PM #6
1: Dust bands in M82 - A (dark, 8")
2: Spiral arms of M61 - E
3: Equatorial dust band of NGC891 - B (dark, 8")
4: Spiral arms of M33 - B (suburban, 80mm)
5: The obscuring cloud of M64 ("Black eye") - B (dark, 8")
6: Spiral arms of M51 - B (dark, 8")
7: Emission nebula, NGC604 in M33 - A (suburban, 8")
8: Dust bands in NGC3556 - E
9: Spiral arms of M99 - E
10: One dust band in the Andromeda galaxy - B (dark, 8")
11: Spiral arms of M101 - D
12: Equatorial dust band of NGC3628 (The one near M65/66) - B (dark, 8")
13: Two dust bands in the Andromeda galaxy - D
14: Emission nebulae in the spiral arms of M101 - E
15: Spiral arms of M100 - E
16: Equatorial dust band of NGC4565 (Coma Berenices) - B (dark, 80mm)
17: "Bend" of galaxy NGC4656 (Canes Venatici) - E
18: Spiral arms of NGC2403 - C (dark, 8")
19: Spiral arms of NGC2903 - E
20: Bridge between M51 and companion galaxy - D

Inge, thanks for setting some interesting winter/spring targets with your list!

Dmitri
Posted 11/17/2006 11:31AM | Edited 11/24/2006 01:47PM #7
Best recollection of observations with 40 inch f5, rural location, NELM varies from 5.5 to 6.5 depending on transparency. Some of the more difficult observations were only possible when transparency was excellent.

1: Dust bands in M82 A
2: Spiral arms of M61 A
3: Equatorial dust band of NGC891 A
4: Spiral arms of M33 A
5: The obscuring cloud of M64 ("Black eye") A
6: Spiral arms of M51 A
7: Emission nebula, NGC604 in M33 A
8: Dust bands in NGC3556 A
9: Spiral arms of M99 A
10: One dust band in the Andromeda galaxy A
11: Spiral arms of M101 A
12: Equatorial dust band of NGC3628 (The one near M65/66) A
13: Two dust bands in the Andromeda galaxy A
14: Emission nebulae in the spiral arms of M101 A
15: Spiral arms of M100 A
16: Equatorial dust band of NGC4565 (Coma Berenices) A
17: "Bend" of galaxy NGC4656 (Canes Venatici) A
18: Spiral arms of NGC2403 A I see spiral structure, arms are not long in this galaxy
19: Spiral arms of NGC2903 A
20: Bridge between M51 and companion galaxy A for bridge, dust lane in bridge on a couple of occasions when very transparent and seeing allowed use of 400-500X

Posted 11/17/2006 09:18PM | Edited 11/17/2006 09:19PM #8
Very few of you claim to have observed galaxy NGC3556. Maybe the reason is that you don't realise that it is the same as M108.

Inge S
Posted 11/18/2006 10:13AM #9
Hi Inge--

You should add "spiral arms of m 81"--but I guess it's too late now. The answers below refer to my 16" under mag 6 or better skies, unless otherwise noted.

1: Dust bands in M82 A
2: Spiral arms of M61 C
3: Equatorial dust band of NGC891 A
4: Spiral arms of M33 A
5: The obscuring cloud of M64 ("Black eye") A
6: Spiral arms of M51 A
7: Emission nebula, NGC604 in M33 A (seen in an 8")
8: Dust bands in NGC3556 You mean M 108? C
9: Spiral arms of M99 C
10: One dust band in the Andromeda galaxy A (seen in 8")
11: Spiral arms of M101 A
12: Equatorial dust band of NGC3628 (The one near M65/66) A
13: Two dust bands in the Andromeda galaxy A
14: Emission nebulae in the spiral arms of M101 A
15: Spiral arms of M100 C
16: Equatorial dust band of NGC4565 (Coma Berenices) A (seen in 4" refractor--very good sky)
17: "Bend" of galaxy NGC4656 (Canes Venatici) A (a favorite along with its big neighbor 4631)
18: Spiral arms of NGC2403 C (I've only looked at this at home under perhaps mag 5 skies--should try it under darker skies...)
19: Spiral arms of NGC2903 C (again, I always seem to be looking at this at home, and not at my dark sky sites...)
20: Bridge between M51 and companion galaxy A

best wishes,
George


George Golitzin