Barlow lens + herschel wedge.

Started by paulsky, 11/08/2008 05:07PM
Posted 11/08/2008 05:07PM Opening Post
Hello,

Anyone know if there is risk if a barlow lens has placing ahead of an Hershel wedge? ..Why? Is dangerous for the Barlow..,for the Herschel wedge or for the eye?

Thanks,
Paul
Posted 11/09/2008 05:24PM #1
Hi Paulo,

I saw your post when you first placed it but I was hesitant to reply for one reason: safety is always an issue when using telescopes to view solar light. I would feel truly horrid if someone was injured because they followed sugestions I made. I would also feel bad if I didn't speak up when I could have prevented an injury. Hopefully others will comment.

Personally, I would not place the Barlow in front of the wedge.
Cemented optics do not fare well in the light path of a solar image. This includes Barlows, eyepieces, filters etc. The cement in these optics can heat up to dangerous levels and fracture the lenses. Even if the glass does not break, the lens is ruined because the cement bond is destroyed by the heat. Additionally, a Barlow lens is placed very close to the image plane so the image will be very intense at that position. If the image gets slightly out of the field of view, the full heat of the sun is going to be shining on the edge of the lens and the lens housing. Like frying bugs with a magnifying glass, it is not something I would want my optics to endure.

Lastly, all lenses have some absorption of the light passing through. Some glasses have more absorption than others. An unfiltered solar image is very intense and even 1% absorption is going to cause a lot of heat to build up.

Solar projection used to be very popular and many telescope kits were equipped with a solar projection screen. However, this was in the time when scopes were equipped with simple eyepieces such as the Ramsden and Hyguens designs which use no cemented elements. If your Barlow uses airspaced lenses,(see ad #595319), you may be able to use it ahead of the wedge, but for the reasons I have stated, I wouldn't do it.

Have fun but play safe,

dan