Comet 17P/Holmes is undergoing a spectacular erupt

Started by kmichaelm, 10/24/2007 09:51PM
Posted 10/24/2007 09:51PM Opening Post
HOT NEWS: Astronomers in Japan, Persia and Europe report that Comet 17P/Holmes is undergoing a spectacular eruption. The 17th magnitude comet has brightened by a factor of five hundred thousand or more during the past 24 hours becoming a naked-eye object in the evening sky. Look for a yellow 2.5th magnitude fuzzball in the constellation Perseus after sunset. [sky map] [ephemeris] [3D orbit]

"This is unbelievable!" says Iranian astronomer Babak Tafreshi. "I was amazed to find Comet Holmes so easily with the naked-eye in the light-polluted skies of metropolitan Tehran." Click on Tafreshi's photo to pinpoint the comet:

The outburst may signify a breakup of the comet's core or a rich vein of ice suddenly exposed to sunlight--no one knows. At present the comet looks more like a star than a comet; it does not have a discernable tail, but it might grow one as the outburst continues. Amateur astronomers are encouraged to monitor developments using binoculars and backyard telescopes. Stay tuned for updates!

Charts at http://www.cometchasing.skyhound.com/

17P/Holmes: An all-night comet visible to the naked eye

This comet is in super outburst, having brightened by many magnitudes on the night of October 24. It is currently (as of 17:00 UT October 24) in Perseus at magnitude 2.8 (and brightening!). Look for a nearly stellar coma in the telescope. It appears as a new star in Perseus to the naked eye. How long this outburst will last is anyone's guess, but according to Gary W. Kronk's Cometography 17P was discovered during a similar outburst in November of 1892. During that outburst it was a naked-eye object for several weeks.

17P is in naked-eye super-outburst! On October 24 this comet brightened to naked-eye visibility! This comet is currently well placed for northern observers in Perseus. It appears very star-like with a reported DC of 9. As of 17:00 UT Seiichi Yoshida (Japan) reports it has brightened to magnitude 2.8. See below for more info and a finder chart.

http://www.cometchasing.skyhound.com/comets/17P.gif


-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Re: [AAVSO-DIS] [cvnet-outburst] Comet Holmes is brilliant object in Perseus
Date: Wed, 24 Oct 2007 20:38:17 +0100
From: Keith Geary
To: , ,
"Baavss"
CC: vsnet alert
References:

Wow!!!!! This is the single most strangest comet I have ever seen in my Life, earlier today, an alert went out that this comet had suddenly brighened from a predicted magnitude 17 to magnitude 3 - incredible, I wonder how this has happened? I quickly set up my 15x70mm binoculars and I easily found it in the constellation Perseus, just about 5 degrees from Alpha Persei at magnitude 1.8, also the star Delta Persei is at magnitude 3.0, from these two stars, I can see the comet at about magnitude 2.5 !!!!! I could immediately see that it is very much yellow in colour, just like the planet Saturn, and it is definitely non star like, with a slighty elongated shape east-west, with no sign of a tail, especially since the near full moon is shining brightly.

This can easily be mistaken for a nova, and is easily visible with the naked eye ! Here is a quick shot that I took.....this will grab many headlines over the next few days...

Keith....

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2277/1731958125_87c03db8e8_o.jpg

----- Original Message -----
From: cnj999
To: [email protected]
Sent: Wednesday, October 24, 2007 7:25 PM
Subject: [cvnet-outburst] Comet Holmes is brilliant object in Perseus


It is perhaps appropriate to warning observers that the 2nd magnitude object visible in northern Perseus is not in fact a new nova but rather Periodic Comet Holmes, which is undergoing an enormous photometric outburst. Undoubtedly, there will be multiple reports of it as a nova (since it appears stellar) as some unsuspecting European observers spot it dramatically altering Perseus' appearance when darkness falls over the continent.

JBortle
Posted 10/25/2007 04:22AM #1
Conditions couldn't have been worse :-( around here in southern CA except clouds of course ;-). The sky was full of smokes from the fire at dust, near full Moon shining brightly. But I could make out two stars in the NE tonight and small what looked like a real dim star below it, none of which were very bright because of the smokes. Slipping in
my 40mm Pentax XL (16x) into my 5-inch NP127 Light Cup, all was clear - it was the comet a roundish, *nonstellar* glow with a hint of a stellar core! The core was easy with my 30mm Ultima (22x) and 12mm Radian (55x). But the best view was through my 2-4mm Nagler zoom (165x-330x) and lots of fun zooming back and forth. At 330x, it looks like a circular glow swirling around (due to bad seeing and wind ;-) a bright round core. No tail :-(. What a sight - I could hardly wait when the smokes clear and clear sky return. Color looked yellowish at low power but I don't rely on it tonight because of the smokes. Later in the session, I couldn't even see the comet naked eye anymore due to more
smokes.

This is the best of my attempt to catch the image with my DSLR and a Tele Vue 2X Barlow. Note a star in the lower left hand corner. Visually it looked a lot of heck better.

Ron B[ee]


Attached Image:

ronbee's attachment for post 117925
Posted 10/25/2007 05:31PM #2
Comet 17/P Holmes is now an *easy* object to see - even from the city.

I can see it naked eye with a nearly full moon in the sky from my heavily light polluted urban location. At first I couldn't believe my eyes - Perseus has an extra star! Then I used 10X50 binoculars and even while hand holding them, I could tell it wasn't quite stellar in
appearance. I got a 3" refractor out and saw what reminded me of a very, very bright planetary nebular such as the Eskimo or Blue Snowball (NGC 2392 or NGC 7662, respectively ), except MUCH brighter and more detailed - with an off-white color in the 3". Just to confirm
that it indeed it bright enough to be seen with the naked eye, I used a green laser to point to it while my girlfriend looked at it through the 3" and saw the laser in the field of view. Yes, it is bright enough to see naked eye under horrible conditions!

Of course, I had to get something bigger on it and setup an 11" dob and .... WOW! I could see it had a very bright, almost stellar pseudo-nucleus, a very bright surrounding coma, and a noticeably dimmer (but still very bright!) outer hood, with no real hint of a tail. A slight elongation of the inner coma could be seen once it got higher in the sky. I see it with a very, very slight tinge of yellow, others see it a more distinct yellow hue.

To find it, see the finder charts ("skymaps") at
http://www.spaceweather.com/

Semi-dark sky naked eye view is similar to this:

http://www.aerith.net/pictures/aguirre/IMG_0957procesada.JPG

This is what kind of view a tripod mounted binocular or small scope will show:

http://www.spaceweather.com/comets/holmes/24oct07/becky-ramotowski-Comet4930_1193289142.jpg?PHPSESSID=36i648fmr2q56klfs70snl56f4
http://tinyurl.com/ynlbxh

Telescope views of this object very much like this Oct. 24, 2007 image by R Richins:

http://www.aerith.net/pictures/richins/Comet_Holmes.jpg

A medium to large sized scope at higher magnifications will show something very much like this view of it as seen by Eric Allen who recorded this view through a 16-inch telescope at the Observatoire du Cégep de Trois-Rivières in Quebec:

http://www.spaceweather.com/comets/holmes/24oct07/Eric-Allen1.jpg?PHPSESSID=36i648fmr2q56klfs70snl56f4
http://tinyurl.com/25gte7

Gary Kronk page on 17P/Holmes:

http://cometography.com/pcomets/017p.html

Wikipedia page on it:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/17P/Holmes
Posted 11/12/2007 05:32AM #3
Finally had some reasonably dark clear skies up here in N. California, and I brought out my 25X power 3 degree FOV 125mm Vixen binoculars.

As I was searching around the bright stars of Perseus, suddenly this massive globe of fuzzy light swung into the FOV. I know the stereo effect is not real when looking at Astronomical objects, but the comet was so obviously in front of the stars, and the whole image simply looked like a giant ball, it took me by surprise. This was a real OMG moment. The effect of one side of the comet being sharp, and the other fuzzy with just a hint of tail in the nucleus made the comet look like it's aimed toward us!

Highly recommended for binocular fans !


David Simons